06/24/2026
The only real striking difference between the Miranda's Rescue scandal and the NBAS scandal is not the allegations themselves.
It is the response of the government agencies involved.
When serious concerns emerged regarding Miranda's Rescue, Humboldt County responded by bringing in the appropriate authorities and allowing investigations to proceed. Local, state, and federal agencies became involved. The focus is on collecting evidence, preserving records, and determining the facts wherever they lead.
The response from the City of Petaluma has been drastically different and purposefully so.
Despite years of complaints, documented oversight failures, Grand Jury findings, missing and altered records, and persistent questions regarding NBAS operations, the City has repeatedly resisted calls for an independent investigation. Indeed they actively shielded NBAS from public complaints. Brian Cochran and Peggy Flynn headed off any criticism of Mark Scott and NBAS with the full power of the government. They covered up for them. And they skirted FOIA laws to hide the truth. To the detriment of the public.
Even more troubling, the City allowed NBAS to leave operation of the shelter without first securing all records necessary to fully evaluate what occurred under the contract. The City had leverage while NBAS was still operating. The City had leverage through final contract payments. The City had leverage through its contractual authority. They never pulled that lever. So critical records remain missing.
That raises a fundamental question:
Why?
If City leadership truly wanted answers, preserving evidence and demanding records would have been the first priority. Instead, the public has watched years of oversight failures followed by a response that appears focused on limiting scrutiny rather than expanding it. Their efforts are to hide their own involvement.
The contrast could not be clearer.
Humboldt County pursued the facts.
Petaluma appears determined to avoid them.
The public deserves to know why one government sought accountability while the other continues to make accountability more difficult.
The innocent have nothing to fear from an investigation.
The guilty do.