10/29/2026
Harsh Handling Almost Killed My Dog
What exactly do I mean when I say “Harsh handling” because if you ask three different trainers what unnecessarily harsh/rough handling is, you will get three different definitions.
My definition of Rough, Unnecessarily Harsh and Man-handling is when you choke dogs out by their collars, roughly shoving dogs, grabbing them by their necks, hanging dogs by their collars, yelling at dogs for “not listening” dragging dogs who are terrified into crates or kennels, using upward leash pressure to demand basic behaviors. Using excessive force unfairly and generally treating a dog like they are an untamed wild beast trying to kill you.
Now back to my hook, “rough handling almost killed my dog” My newest addition Kuvira is a 1-year-old Malinois puppy who was brought to a shelter because of her excessive energy. Right out of the gate breed stereotypes such as “Malinois are difficult” “Mals need a firm hand” and “Malinois BITE” were applied to Kuvira, who in all honesty is a sweet loving dog who just has a LOT of energy. She has a very low bite threshold but a very high bite inhibition, meaning that while she does bite/mouth very easily it takes an extreme amount of pressure to make her bite hard. Or at least it did.
Kuvira does not enjoy being forced into a confined area, who does? She will pull back, toss and throw herself around, and will snap using her mouth to communicate “I DO NOT WANT TO GO IN” she is also extremely food motivated and will go into a crate or kennel for some hotdogs and with some patience. But unfortunately some of the well meaning volunteers and staff at the shelter used brute Force/ unnecessarily harsh handling to get Kuvira back into her kennel. I witnessed this myself. She put up quite a fight.
One of the volunteers one day, I'm sure, was very frustrated because she had a reaction to something and “didn't listen to the verbal correction”, strung Kuvira up by her neck while yelling at her and Kuvira, responding with force because of force, delivered a Level 4 bite. She was treated like a dangerous Malinois so she became a dangerous Malinois.
She had a much harder time with pressure after that incident, she was quicker to escalate her communication with other people (aka getting mouthy and wild), and she was almost slotted for behavioral euthanasia. An unnecessary death because of unnecessary harsh handling. She's not a dangerous dog naturally, she's just a high energy working dog puppy with Zero Impulse Control Training. Forceful handling made her into “a dangerous Malinois”.
Her story ended happily because of an absolutely wonderful saint of a Volunteer who saw she was just a scared under -stimulated dog that needed help and offered her gentle and kind handling with a focus on patience and teaching her skills.
I do not blame the volunteers or staff members at that shelter, they did not know better and only did what they thought was right. They were doing their best with the education they had and the environment they were in. I am grateful that Kuvira was allowed to be brought to me. Although I am saddened by the circumstances in which it happened.
But this is why I am making this post. To spread awareness to people who don't know any better, to people who need to take a good long hard look at their treatment of dogs and what they're doing. This isn't about loving dogs, everyone who volunteers and works in a shelter loves dogs. But Intention does not negate impact and rough/forceful handling has an extremely serious, sometimes deadly, impact on the dogs who experience it.
I have personal experience with unnecessarily forceful and unkind handling with my own dogs. I am not innocent. I have been unnecessarily harsh with past dogs, with Kuvira even. I was wrong to do some of the things I've done with her in the heat of my frustration. I have dragged her into her room by her collar and yelled at her because of my own dysregulation and frustration and her refusal to “just get into the goddamn room already I'm going to be late goddamn it. Why won't you just LISTEN” I have screamed and thrown objects (never at the dogs thankfully) because of my own anger. I have anger issues and an extremely low frustration tolerance naturally, combined with medical conditions that cause an even lower frustration tolerance if I don't take my pill and you get an extremely reactive person.
And Kuvira has responded to that harsh handling by snapping, by being harder to handle, by mouthing but tolerantly never biting. Because she's a sweet kind dog.
It's my job to keep myself in check, and it shouldn't be my dogs who take the blunt of my own frustration. It's every person who works with dogs Job to keep themselves in check. No matter how much the animal is frustrating you.
And guess what? Whenever I stop, I think and I make a
management plan to set her and myself up for success, such as making her room into a much more fun place where we play games and get high value pepperonis so she's more happy to go in there, handling her gets easier, and she's no longer fighting me.
Our dogs need to be treated with kindness, empathy and understanding. Not force, not rough handling, and not in frustration.
Get your treat pouch, give your dog time and *go at their pace*