08/27/2026
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1Bt4r1V2ZV/
š¾ DISCUSSION TIME ā Breeder of Merit⦠or Is There a Money Game Involved? š°š¤
Now before anybody gets their panties in a wad, I am NOT saying being an AKC Breeder of Merit means nothing. There are legitimate requirements behind the program, and producing titled dogs, health testing and putting years into a breed absolutely deserve recognition.
BUTā¦
Thereās one requirement that makes my Southern eyebrow go WAY up. š¤Ø
Breeders in the program commit to 100% individual AKC registration of the puppies they produce.
So letās talk about Martha. š
Martha buys a beautiful pet puppy.
You give Martha the AKC paperwork.
You explain the paperwork.
You remind Martha about the paperwork.
Martha takes it home, lays it beside the electric bill, a Walmart receipt and a coupon that expired six months agoā¦
And Martha never registers the dang dog. š¤¦āāļø
Did that change the puppyās structure? No.
Temperament? No.
Health testing behind the breeding? No.
Did it erase decades of studying pedigrees, showing dogs, producing champions and trying to improve a breed?
Absolutely not.
But it DOES affect that 100% registration requirement.
Now hereās where my question about the money game comes in.
Whatās the easiest way to make sure Martha doesnāt mess up your percentage?
Register the puppy yourself.
And what does every individual registration require?
š° A registration fee.
Multiply that by every puppy in every litter from breeders trying to maintain those numbers and suddenly thatās a whole lot of registrationsāand a whole lot of money going somewhere.
So I think itās perfectly fair to ask:
Is 100% registration really measuring the MERIT of a breeder⦠or is part of this program also a very effective way of encouraging more paid AKC registrations?
Because if weāre going to use the word MERIT, I want merit to mean something.
Health.
Temperament.
Structure.
Knowledge.
Longevity.
Titles produced.
Standing behind your puppies.
Improving your breed generation after generation.
Those things tell me about the breeder.
Whether Martha mailed in her registration tells me something about Martha. š
Again, Iām not knocking the accomplishments of anyone who has earned Breeder of Merit. There are some phenomenal breeders carrying that designation.
Iām questioning one particular requirement and whether it truly measures breeding excellence.
So letās discuss it:
Is requiring 100% individual puppy registration a reasonable standard for Breeder of Merit⦠or does that requirement make the program feel at least partly like a MONEY GAME? š°š
Because poor Martha may be forgetfulā¦
but apparently sheās holding somebodyās merit hostage on her kitchen counter. š¤£š¤£