10/29/2026
**We’ve been saying it for years: dogs need affection, clear expectations, and skills that work in everyday life. 🐾**
Cody O'Kelly here. A recent Wall Street Journal article brings a familiar debate into the spotlight.
Trainer Brian Lee argues that some owners are overindulging their dogs. Veterinarian and animal behaviorist Dr. Ian Dunbar identifies “far too many food rewards” as a major problem in training today.
**At HHH Canine Lodge & Ranch, this conversation is familiar because we work with families still struggling after previous training.**
Some come to us after positive-only programs, with older dogs, unresolved original problems, and owners whose lives increasingly revolve around managing their dog’s behavior.
Walks are stressful. Having visitors takes planning. Everyday activities become difficult. Families have invested time, money, and effort—and still need help.
That deserves a thoughtful response and a clear plan.
**Here’s why we choose balanced training.**
🐾 **We want the dog to learn the skill beyond the food lure.**
Food is a valuable teaching tool, and we use it. But there’s a difference between rewarding a response and needing to display a treat before the dog will respond.
Our goal is to teach clear cues, practice gradually around distractions, and help owners carry those skills into everyday situations. Continuing to reward behavior is useful; the concern is getting stuck without a plan for progress.
🐾 **We teach boundaries and alternatives together.**
Waiting at a doorway. Keeping four paws on the floor. Walking without dragging a person down the sidewalk. Settling when playtime ends.
Dogs can learn these skills through patient instruction and consistent expectations. Saying “no” alone doesn’t explain what to do instead.
🐾 **We look at what the whole day is teaching.**
If pulling repeatedly gets a dog where it wants to go, pulling can pay off. If demanding attention consistently works, that pattern can continue.
Training sessions need support from everyday routines. Owners need practical guidance they can follow consistently.
🐾 **We consider physical health alongside behavior.**
Training treats count toward a dog’s daily calories. Adding frequent treats on top of full meals can contribute to excess weight.
The American Animal Hospital Association recommends keeping treats and extras to no more than 10% of daily calories. Another option is to use a measured portion of the dog’s regular food for training.
Good training should support a healthy body, too.
**Our approach includes rewards, structure, clear communication, and fair corrections when necessary.**
We assess each dog, explain our approach to the owner, and watch how the dog responds. We also examine confusion, fear, discomfort, and unrealistic expectations before assuming a dog is deliberately ignoring us.
Reward-based trainers can teach boundaries, too. Our experience with families who need additional help doesn’t prove that one method caused every problem. It does explain why we believe owners deserve an individual plan and an honest assessment when progress has stalled.
**We want families to enjoy life with their dogs—and feel equipped to guide them through it.**
Pictured: **Murphy, a client GSP, enjoying his regular pack hike.**
Read Jamie Waters’s article in The Wall Street Journal:
https://apple.news/AO48gAHznRvKlndMxkMJ9Eg
Learn about HHH’s training:
https://www.hhhcanines.com/training
Treat and calorie guidance:
https://www.aaha.org/resources/2021-aaha-nutrition-and-weight-management-guidelines/prevention-of-obesity/