First Choice for Pets

Directions Website Contact the business

First Choice for Pets First Choice for Pets aims to be your one stop shop for pet food and accessories. We offer local holistic options as well as national brands.

We love your pets like they're our own and want them to live a long and happy life! :)

🎃 TRICK OR FOLLOW? 👻Happy Halloween from First Choice for Pets in Stouffville!Our spooky squad reported for duty and the...
10/31/2026

🎃 TRICK OR FOLLOW? 👻

Happy Halloween from First Choice for Pets in Stouffville!

Our spooky squad reported for duty and they are NOT playing around. 😂

We need YOUR help settling the big debate at the store today:

Who wins BEST COSTUME?

1️⃣ Demon Hunters Dog 👻
2️⃣ Peppa Pig Kitty 🐷
3️⃣ Michael Meowers 🔪
4️⃣ Freddy Krue-claws 😹
5️⃣ Rambo Pup 💪

VOTE with the number in the COMMENTS 👇 and tell us what YOUR pet is dressing up as this year!

We'll share our favorite pet costumes from the comments in our Stories. Extra points if you tag a friend who needs to see this lineup.

Same great pets. More to love. 💙🐾

P.S. Hit Follow for more paw-some content, pet tips, store updates & Halloween specials!

Does your cat go crazy for TUNA CUTS IN GRAVY? 😻Your tuna lover NEEDS to try this!BLUE Buffalo Tastefuls Savoury Singles...
10/30/2026

Does your cat go crazy for TUNA CUTS IN GRAVY? 😻

Your tuna lover NEEDS to try this!

BLUE Buffalo Tastefuls Savoury Singles - Tuna Entrée CUTS IN GRAVY

Single-serve cups, no messy leftovers, made with real tuna first. Perfect for picky cats who love to lick that gravy clean.

In stock NOW at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville for just $1.99!

Question for you 👇
Is your cat a gravy-licker first or do they dive straight for the meat? Drop your cat's name + their answer in the comments - we want to meet our local tuna fans!

YES, WE HAVE HARNESSES! 🎉🐾You asked, we listened!We LOVE Rogz adjustable step-in harnesses because they're:✅ No hassle t...
10/30/2026

YES, WE HAVE HARNESSES! 🎉🐾

You asked, we listened!

We LOVE Rogz adjustable step-in harnesses because they're:
✅ No hassle to put on — just step in and clip, no over-the-head wrestling
✅ Fully adjustable for the perfect, comfy fit
✅ Reflective stitching for those late fall walks

Just look at these colours we have in stock now — hot pink, red, and blue! 😍

We want to know — what colour would YOUR pup rock?
Pink 💖 , Red ❤️ , or Blue 💙 ? Drop it in the comments!

👇 Tag a dog parent who needs a harness upgrade!

In stock now at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville — come try one on!

🐾 TEAM TURKEY 🦃 vs TEAM BEEF 🐄 - What does your pet vote?Has your dog or cat tried Open Farm Bone Broths yet?!It's the e...
10/30/2026

🐾 TEAM TURKEY 🦃 vs TEAM BEEF 🐄 - What does your pet vote?

Has your dog or cat tried Open Farm Bone Broths yet?!

It's the easiest way to level up mealtime:
💧 Adds moisture to kibble & raw
✨ Supports healthy skin + joints (rich in collagen)
😋 Human-grade meal topper that even the pickiest eaters love!

We have both flavours in stock right now at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville:
🥣 Homestead Turkey Bone Broth
🥣 Grass-Fed Beef Bone Broth

Just pour, serve, and watch that bowl disappear!

👇 We want to hear from you! Drop a 🦃 or 🐄 in the comments and tell us your pet's name + which flavour they'd pick! Bonus points - how do YOU use bone broth at home?

In-store now for $9.99!

Does your cat lick ALL the gravy first and save the chunks for later? 😹👇If you've got a chunks-in-gravy fan at home, the...
10/30/2026

Does your cat lick ALL the gravy first and save the chunks for later? 😹👇

If you've got a chunks-in-gravy fan at home, they need to try this:

Natural Balance Turkey & Duck Morsels in Gravy - grain-free, real turkey & duck, and that irresistible gravy cats go CRAZY for.

We have it in stock now at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville for just $2.49!

Tell us in the comments: Is your cat Team GRAVY FIRST or Team MORSELS FIRST? 🍗

Tag a fellow cat parent who needs to grab one!

📍 First Choice for Pets - Stouffville

🐶 That full-body SHAKE after playtime... what does it really mean?Same shake. Different reasons! 👇Have you ever noticed ...
10/30/2026

🐶 That full-body SHAKE after playtime... what does it really mean?

Same shake. Different reasons! 👇

Have you ever noticed your pup shaking after getting super excited to see you, or after a stressful vet visit? That little shake-off is actually their way of resetting.

What that shaking can mean:

😊 EXCITEMENT - After play, a walk, or greeting their favorite human. It's short-lived, usually with a wagging tail and wiggly, relaxed body. Pure happy energy!

😟 STRESS or ANXIETY - During loud noises, new places, vet visits, or when they feel unsure. Look for tucked ears, wide eyes, or a lowered body. They're trying to calm themselves down.

🌡️ OTHER CAUSES - Can also mean feeling cold, pain, or other medical concerns - especially if it's ongoing, frequent, or doesn't stop.

Why context is EVERYTHING:
The same shake can mean two totally different things. Always look at the whole picture - their body language, where they are, and what JUST happened. That's how you know what they're really feeling.

We see this all the time at the shop!

Tell us in the comments — When does YOUR dog do the shake-off the most? After the zoomies? Car rides? Greeting you at the door? Let's compare notes! 👇

Need help reading your pup's signals? Come chat with us in-store - we're always happy to help.

Healthy Pets. Happy Lives. 💙
First Choice for Pets • STOUFFVILLE

Is your cat a catnip fanatic? We need to talk... 😼👀We just restocked YEOWWW! - super-charged, organically grown catnip t...
10/28/2026

Is your cat a catnip fanatic? We need to talk... 😼👀

We just restocked YEOWWW! - super-charged, organically grown catnip that cats go absolutely CRAZY for. This isn't the weak stuff. This is THE good stuff. 💥

On the wall right now:
💚 The Green Fish
🤎 The Catnip Cigar
⚽ My Cats Balls

If you know, you KNOW.

Question for you: Which one would YOUR cat destroy first? 👇

Team FISH? Team CIGAR? Or Team BALLS? Drop your answer in the comments and post a pic of your catnip-crazy kitty - we want to see them!

Available now at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville - they go fast!

🐱 LITTER BOX TALK - Let's be honest...Need a litter that ACTUALLY clumps well and controls odour?Our fan favorite by FAR...
10/28/2026

🐱 LITTER BOX TALK - Let's be honest...

Need a litter that ACTUALLY clumps well and controls odour?

Our fan favorite by FAR is Odour Buster Original - and it's all in the name! 🇨🇦 This Canadian brand is unscented, clumps like a dream, and is made to keep your home odour-free for up to 30 days.

It's the one our cat parents come back for again and again.

We want to know from you 👇
What's your #1 litter box struggle? Is it the odour, the tracking, or finding one that clumps properly? And are you Team UNSCENTED or Team SCENTED?

Drop your answer in the comments - we read and reply to every single one! Bonus points if you tell us how many cats rule your house. 😸

Available in-store now at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville. Come grab a bag and see why it's our bestseller!

Has your dog or cat recently come off medication? 👀Their liver, kidneys, pancreas and gallbladder do all the heavy lifti...
10/28/2026

Has your dog or cat recently come off medication? 👀

Their liver, kidneys, pancreas and gallbladder do all the heavy lifting to filter and reset. Give them some extra love with gentle herbal support.

We have Adored Beast Liver Tonic back in stock at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville for $29.99 - same one in the photo!

Liver Tonic is a gentle herbal blend designed to support normal liver and digestive function in dogs and cats. It supports the health of the liver by helping regenerate healthy liver cells and boost the organ's ability to filter toxins, and helps support, detox and repair the liver, kidney, pancreas and gallbladder function.

Made with time honored ingredients like dandelion root, milk thistle, and barberry, made in Canada, for dogs and cats.

We want to hear from you!
Has your pup or kitty finished antibiotics, flea and tick meds, or anything else this season? Drop a 🐶 or 🐱 below and tell us what they finished. What is your go-to after-care routine?

Tag a pet parent who needs to know about this and comment LIVER and we will DM you the dosage guide.

📍 Available now in store at First Choice for Pets, Stouffville

🐟 PSA FOR TUNA-OBSESSED CATS 🐟If your cat comes running every time you crack open a can of tuna... this treat was MADE f...
10/28/2026

🐟 PSA FOR TUNA-OBSESSED CATS 🐟

If your cat comes running every time you crack open a can of tuna... this treat was MADE for them!

Say hello to Crémia Sensitive Stomach, Skin & Coat - Tuna Formula 😻

Why we love it at First Choice for Pets in Stouffville:

✨ Tuna is the #1 ingredient - real protein, real flavour
✨ Lickable, creamy texture that even picky cats go crazy for
✨ Grain free and gentle on sensitive tummies
✨ Canadian, family-owned since 2000 with oven-baked tradition
✨ High moisture content to help support hydration and urinary tract health - so important for kitties!

It is a treat that is delicious AND does something good.

We want to know from you:

👇 Is your cat Team TUNA, Team CHICKEN, or Team SHRIMP? Drop your answer in the comments + your cat's name! Bonus points if you post a pic of your tuna lover in action 👇

Available now in store - 12 tubes per pack!

Address

15301 Highway 48
Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON
L4A7X4

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 6:30pm
Tuesday 9am - 6:30pm
Wednesday 9am - 7pm
Thursday 9am - 7pm
Friday 9am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when First Choice for Pets posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to First Choice for Pets:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby pet stores & pet services

Other Pet Stores in Whitchurch-Stouffville

Show All