Kommetjie Canine College

Directions Website Contact the business

Kommetjie Canine College A training school for dogs of all ages: from puppy socialisation classes to Advanced Trick Training

What The Actual?I find myself saying this increasingly these days. Despite deliberately not following the social media p...
27/10/2026

What The Actual?

I find myself saying this increasingly these days.
Despite deliberately not following the social media pages of (un)balanced trainers to save myself the distress of witnessing abuse which I am unable to do anything about, I have still stumbled upon some things which I just cannot get my head around, mostly on dog training advice forums, which my algorithm seems to think I need to see.

In the last week I have come across:
• Someone who’s two Rottweilers escaped the property - and I use that phrase loosely, as the dogs were fitted with boundary fence e-collars and there was no actual physical barrier – defending their impeccable status as responsible dog owners, because it is not their fault that the shock collars malfunctioned – there aren’t enough facepalm emojis in the world……
• A man garrotting a small breed dog with a slip-lead for about 10 minutes in an attempt to teach the dog to sit, because clearly that is the easiest method. In the time it was taking him to achieve precisely nothing, we had taught 9 puppies to sit, down, stand and come only that morning, with completely novice owners and a clicker and treats – and no dogs needed their air supply cut off to achieve that – who would have thought….
• A man advocating keeping dogs in kennels for extended periods, because you need to deprive them of basic freedom and enjoyment so that they are more “grateful” to you when you take them out and work with them, because otherwise, they will be like spoiled children – we all know that children deprived of their basic needs are so much better off.
• Someone asking for advice about their dog’s attempts to shake off the shock collar that has not just one box with a set of prongs to zap the dog, but two – you know, so you can distribute the electric shock more evenly around the neck. Seriously. Do people not hear themselves?

I could go on, but I think you get the idea.

I know that people will ask what the point of writing about this is or say that I am preaching to the choir or in an echo chamber, but I think these things actually do need to be aired from time to time, because there is so much emphasis on “tolerance” towards trainers we may disagree with and finding common ground with the “other side”, because “we all love dogs”, that I think we forget just what the other side’s ideology breeds.

Yes, of course there are degrees of force, degrees of pain, degrees of intimidation and different intensities of aversives. Yes, you will get some trainers who use aversives with good timing and some trainers who use aversives with bad timing. You will get some trainers who believe aversives are only justified occasionally and others who use them for everything and you will get some trainers who add lots of positive stuff to the scale and others who add very little.

However, at the end of the day, once you make a conscious, calculated decision to apply force or pain as part of a training plan, it is a slippery slope to increasing that force and pain when you aren’t getting the results that you want. If you believe that there is a scenario that justifies you deliberately hurting or frightening a dog to teach them a behaviour, there will always be justification for increasing the fear or pain for some other behaviour and this is how we end up with the ridiculous scenarios I recounted above.

The conflict between balanced trainers and force free trainers is not really about efficiency, practicalities or scientific research (although these support force free training), it is about a fundamental moral belief: Either you believe that animals deserve to experience pain and fear during the training process or you believe that they have a right to be protected from the deliberate application of pain and fear.

I keep using words like “deliberate”, “intentional”, “calculated”, because I am referring to those who act with the intention to apply force, pain or intimidation as part of the planned training process and not the person who gets a fright or has a bad day and yells at their dog occasionally or who has to restrain their dog with force in an unexpected emergency. Yes, life happens and we are all imperfect human beings in an imperfect world, but the occasional grumpy moment with a family member (which is what our dogs should be) where we act with less kindness than we should is a far cry from deciding that it is totally justified to routinely hurt and frighten that canine family member to get what we want. It is the difference between a normal family relationship and an abusive one.

And this is why I don’t believe there can be any tolerance for those who knowingly choose “training methods” that use force, pain and fear. It is physical and psychological abuse. Someone who says that they hit their spouse only when it is “really necessary” is still hitting their spouse. Would you tolerate that and look for common ground with them?

Huge Congratulations to everyone who passed their various Canine Good Citizen levels this Sunday 🏵👏🏆 You and your dogs a...
20/10/2026

Huge Congratulations to everyone who passed their various Canine Good Citizen levels this Sunday 🏵👏🏆 You and your dogs all did extremely well 🐾🤗

08/10/2026

We want your puppies!
Puppy Classes are one of the most important services we offer, because a good foundation during the socialisation period is crucial for your puppy's adult emotional wellbeing. This means that we want them from 10 weeks of age, not when they are already 16 weeks old and the prime socialisation period is over. Don't delay, join in the fun today! 🐾🖤🤎
Email [email protected] for enquiries

Yes, yes and yes again - it is not your dog's job to regulate you or your child's emotions - end of story. https://www.f...
30/09/2026

Yes, yes and yes again - it is not your dog's job to regulate you or your child's emotions - end of story.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1Mfgkgq4N8/

For clarity - I have no issue with TRAINED SERVICE DOGS - two key words here…. . Dogs & trained.

This post is about the fashion of getting pups and expecting them to be emotional support animals as puppies - and assuming that every dog can do it!

Assistance / service task trained dogs are one thing (and not every dog is suited) but this fashion of EMOTIONAL SUPPORT PUPPIES being sent into schools at 10 weeks old to be the school emotional support dog is outrageous and needs to stop.
People buying pups and expecting them to cope with meltdowns / episodes of neurodivergent people is outrageous and needs to stop. It’s happening with 8/10/12/14 week old PUPPIES

Not EVERY dog can be an assistance dog & that’s ok. It’s a very tough job and not every dog will enjoy it.
Not even every dog from purposely bred, professionally trained specialist organisations will make it. So it’s unreasonable to expect that every pup sourced from any random place will be suitable.

Assistance / service task trained dogs are one thing (and not every dog is suited) but this fashion of EMOTIONAL SUPPORT PUPPIES being sent into schools at 10 weeks old to be the school emotional support dog is outrageous and needs to stop.
People buying pups and expecting them to cope with meltdowns / episodes of neurodivergent people is outrageous and needs to stop. 8/10/12/14 week old PUPPIES

People buying dogs and expecting them to cope and actually help just because they’re there. No training - not even loose lead walking and then banishing them to live in the garden (yard) coz they bark - actual case.

Even the new fashion of therapy with puppies- marketed as meditation / yoga / group healing/ trauma processing etc with puppies - I’ve seen clips of grown adults crying out loud into the fur of puppies , or “letting it all out” shouting and wailing whilst some poor pup is there with no support…. (Have to hand it to the “therapist” - great marketing, and a great revenue spinner- get paid for people to view the pup AND charge thousands for the pup that “broke down your barriers to healing”)

So I’ll say again PUPPIES are not there to emotionally regulate, take responsibility for, mitigate or support any behaviour, neurodivergence or emotional issues.

And just because a dog is a wonderful pet does not make them a good working dog.

I have no issues with TRAINED service DOGS, Provided they are appropriately selected & trained and have the temperament for the job. (If service dogs need to be in e collars and prongs to “behave” in public I personally think they’re in the wrong job) service dogs should be IMO, self confident, self contained, good impulse control, fit, be genuinely comfortable in the environments where they need to work. I love to see service dogs work, I used to train them, and watching a well matched partnership is an absolute joy.

Service dogs and emotional support dogs are very different things and i have major issue with puppies being thrown in a the deep end with no training and expected to cope. It’s unfair, it’s unreasonable and entitled. It’s a ticking bomb ….. and some poor child somewhere is going to end up with a face scarred for life, and the dog will be PTS.

It’s not ok and it needs to stop.

—————————————————————————

The entitlement is getting worse and it’s driving me crazy.

This month alone I’ve been asked about :

- buying a pup for a child with autism (but they didn’t want to wait for a charity)
- putting a pup into a school to help regulate “problem behaviours”
- certifying a pet dog so that they can get access rights
- rehoming a dog coz they bought it for a child with autism but “it doesn’t do anything & pulls on the lead” but they wouldn’t pay a trainer - they thought any dog would do 🤷‍♀️

Pet dogs are not working dogs.

I’m all for working dogs - but do it right.
You cannot just take a child and sit them in a psychiatrist’s chair, deal with issues and expect it to be ok just coz they’re sweet kind children.

Same with puppies - JUST STOP THE CRAZY PLEASE!

If there is one thing that absolutely stumps me, it is people who take their dogs out with absolutely nothing on the dog...
11/09/2026

If there is one thing that absolutely stumps me, it is people who take their dogs out with absolutely nothing on the dog that they can get hold of in an emergency.

Having worked with dogs for over 25 years, I have had to catch a dog or two in my time. Catching and restraining a dog in a state of high arousal is no easy task, but it becomes next to impossible if the dog is not wearing a harness or collar. Trying to hold onto a leg, tail or scruff is not a secure or safe way to restrain a dog – you may hurt the dog and you are unlikely to be able to prevent the dog from slipping away again and going back to whatever it was that you were trying to get them away from.

Yet there is a percentage of people who are totally resistant to common sense and who seem to lack the most basic foresight with regards to the safety of their dogs and the public good.

Alarmingly, many of them seem to own the types of dogs most at risk for doing serious damage if something goes wrong. In March this year, I wrote a similar post after two pit bulls, one of which was displaying very uncomfortable behaviour, approached Ozzy, while the owner chatted on her cell phone a distance away – the dogs had no collars or harnesses and the owner had no leads with her. This week, while strolling through the wetlands with Jedi (my horse) I encountered another woman with two pit bulls and again there were no collars or harnesses on the dogs and no leads on the person. The one dog immediately made a beeline for Jedi while the woman tried to recall her in vain. Jedi and I stayed calm and still, but the dog became increasingly aroused and made several runs at Jedi, coming in from behind and starting to bark excitedly. I am grateful to have a calm horse who did not react, other than to eventually flick a hind leg in warning. The dog seemed to get the message and eventually went back to the owner.

But what if Jedi was not so calm? What if he had started to jump around in fright or tried to run, as many horses would do? This was very much a predator/prey type scenario, with the dog clearly trying to get Jedi to move, so that she could chase – what if things had escalated and this dog had really gone for Jedi? How would any of us have gotten hold of the dog or restrained her? This is not an unheard-of scenario - there have been several incidents just like that in this area where dogs have physically launched at and bitten horses and have had to be caught and restrained to prevent further injury to the horse. How do you do that with a dog that has no collar or harness, especially when they are pumped up and intent on going back for more?

I know I am going to be in trouble for mentioning the breed of the dogs, but a good 80% of the dogs I see with zero collars, harnesses or available leads are bull breeds or bull breed mixes. The other over-represented breed is ridgebacks – and coincidentally in our area they are also over-represented in various problematic incidents. These types of dogs are sleek, muscular and short-coated, which makes them especially difficult to hold onto without a secure harness or collar.

No dog should ever be out in public without a collar or harness and without the guardian carrying a functioning lead. I do not understand the level of arrogance it takes to believe that your dog could never possibly do anything where you might need to get hold of them – or is it just a total lack of imagination and common sense? When I see someone strolling along like this, I can only conclude that they are completely stupid or so entitled that they do not care if their dog causes a problem for someone else.

No matter how well-trained any of my dogs have been, they have always worn harnesses and I have always carried leads with me, even in off-leash areas. The reality is that anything can happen at any time and one must be prepared to be able to physically control a dog if the need arises – even if it seems unlikely that anything might go wrong. No matter how well-trained or sociable a dog is, they are still a complex sentient being and their behaviour is influenced by many internal and external factors - we can never predict with 100% certainty how they may respond on a particular day in particular circumstances - and we cannot predict what might happen in the world around us when we go out. The only way to be responsible, is to be prepared.

Incidentally, it also needs to be said that if you are taking a dog out in public, you need to be physically able to restrain that dog on lead if the need arises. If you are not physically able to manage a dog, you should not be taking that dog out on your own. It is not “ableist” to say this, it is basic logic. If you were unable to safely operate a motor vehicle, you would be prohibited from driving – if you cannot safely manage a dog, the same should apply.

Freedom is important for dogs and there is nothing better than watching a dog explore and enjoy the environment around them on a walk. It is wonderful that we have off-leash areas where dogs can have this opportunity. Not having a collar or harness on your dog and not carrying a lead is an abuse of that privilege and for what? It is the easiest thing in the world to just put something on the dog and have a lead with you. There is no excuse.

I was reminded of this article that I wrote in 2019 about the importance of allowing our dogs to communicate with us by ...
23/08/2026

I was reminded of this article that I wrote in 2019 about the importance of allowing our dogs to communicate with us by an interesting post by another trainer, sharing how her Rottweilers communicate and asking for others views and experiences. In our work we come across a variety of dog guardians: some who are finely tuned to what their dogs are communicating and others who don't seem to notice until communication gets very "big".

Listening to our dogs communication helps us to understand and meet their needs and so reduce frustration and the behavioural fallout from that.

I thought this article was worth sharing again 🐾😊

-----‐-----------------------------------------------
SHOULD DOGS BE ABLE TO GIVE US CUES?

Traditional thinking and has always been along the lines of “You should control your dog; they shouldn’t control you”. People seen to give into their dogs’ requests were told disparagingly that they were allowing their dogs to train them. Furthermore, dogs were expected to jump through all sorts of human-designed hoops before they received anything from us at all (e.g. nothing in life is free programmes).

But there has thankfully been a revolution in how we raise and train dogs and one of the things we are so much more aware of these days is the importance of control when it comes to emotional wellbeing. Being able to exercise some control over things in life is empowering. Having no control over anything can lead to frustration, stress and eventually depression.

Imagine moving to a country where no one spoke your language and you did not have a clue how to communicate your needs. Imagine that every time you attempted to gesture that you needed something or tried to help yourself to something, you were verbally or physically assaulted. Imagine if the people you can’t communicate with decided that every time they deigned to give you something, you needed to sit down or stand on your head and until you figured out what they wanted and did it, you got nothing.

Sounds awful, doesn’t it? Yet, this is exactly the situation that many dogs face throughout their lives. The reality is that we do control pretty much everything in our dogs’ lives. We decide when they eat (and what they eat and how much they eat), we decide when they get to go for a walk (and where they walk and for how long they walk), we decide whether they get to meet other dogs and people, we decided when to play with them, when or if to train and work with them, what toys they can have and where they can sleep. We even control when they have access to us and our homes and for how long. Every aspect of their lives is under our control. So how do we ensure that our dogs do not feel helpless, frustrated, stressed or depressed? Well, we need to give them back control by opening the lines of communication and allowing them to show us what they want and need.

Modern dog training focuses far more on encouraging dogs to be active participants in the training process, by reinforcing them for engaging with us, for offering behaviours, for problem solving and trying new things. This is a very different approach to traditional training, where a dog was expected to do nothing until cued and any initiative shown by the dog was frowned upon. In this sense, by making the dog an active role player in training, we are giving them back some control over the training process and allowing the dog to guide us as to how quickly we can progress from one step to the next. They are able to initiate exercises and, while we may set the environment up to encourage them to perform a certain behaviour, in many cases, from the dog’s perspective they are choosing what to do and figuring it out for themselves. As a result, the level of engagement and enthusiasm we see in dogs in our classes these days is huge in comparison to more traditional schools, even where positive reinforcement is used, but where the dogs are expected to do nothing until they are told what to do.

But it is not just in training that we need to consider allowing our dogs to have more control. We need to consider how we can give our dogs back some control over their everyday needs. We should be aware of what our dogs are asking for and we should be willing and ready to help them. Rosie and Cruz have many ways of asking for things:

1. Rosie will paw the bed, when she wants to get on – she doesn’t need help getting up, but seems to want encouragement, so I say: “Good Girl, up you go!” and she will spring up and settle down.
2. Cruz will stand and stare at the water bucket and then look back at us – this means the water is not fresh enough and he wants us to fill it up.
3. Rosie will moan just a little if Cruz is lying in the way and she can’t get past – she will look at him and look at me and make little noises. She is asking me to ask Cruz to move slightly so she can come through.
4. Late in the afternoon, I usually start getting stared at – this means that supper time is nigh!
5. Both dogs will go stand at the door to go out.
6. Cruz will go to and scratch on our bedroom door at night (which is open), if he wants to get back on the bed with us, but it is too dark for him to see where he is going to land – he wants us to switch on the light so he can see what he is doing.
7. Every morning, Cruz does a little dance that ends in a curtsy (bow) or rest (putting his chin on the ground), because he wants us to get a ball off the bookshelf, to start the day off right.
8. Every time Rosie comes inside after going to the toilet, she runs and stares at the biscuit tin, because she wants a biscuit.
9. Cruz will stare at the “chew” tin where I keep sinews when he is in the mood for something to chew.
10. In the evening, Rosie will paw the pillows on the dog couch, so we can move them so she has space to get up.

We generally respond to all these requests from our dogs. They are not unreasonable requests and they are all for things that make their lives comfortable and cause us no harm whatsoever. These little things help our dogs to have some control over the good things in their lives and keep them willing to communicate and engage with us. The key is to identify subtle and polite cues from your dog and respond to those, before they become less subtle and possibly inappropriate. I am sure that many dogs “demand” bark, because it is the only thing they have found that is annoying enough to actually get a response from their humans. Every other subtle signal is ignored and barking becomes the only successful option. If you want to avoid having a dog that barks to get you to listen, start looking for other ways your dog may be communicating their needs and responding to those.

These days we like to claim that our dogs are our partners and not our slaves, so why should we be the only ones ever allowed to ask for anything? Our dogs should be able to ask for things. If we allow them to do so, we can give them back some of the control that we have over their lives and make an enormous contribution to their emotional wellbeing.

Photo: Cruz doing his best "Please can I have my ball" curtsy 🥰

SHOULD DOGS BE ABLE TO GIVE US CUES?

Traditional thinking and has always been along the lines of “You should control your dog; they shouldn’t control you”. People seen to give into their dogs’ requests were told disparagingly that they were allowing their dogs to train them. Furthermore, dogs were expected to jump through all sorts of human-designed hoops before they received anything from us at all (e.g. nothing in life is free programmes).

But there has thankfully been a revolution in how we raise and train dogs and one of the things we are so much more aware of these days is the importance of control when it comes to emotional wellbeing. Being able to exercise some control over things in life is empowering. Having no control over anything can lead to frustration, stress and eventually depression.

Imagine moving to a country where no one spoke your language and you did not have a clue how to communicate your needs. Imagine that every time you attempted to gesture that you needed something or tried to help yourself to something, you were verbally or physically assaulted. Imagine if the people you can’t communicate with decided that every time they deigned to give you something, you needed to sit down or stand on your head and until you figured out what they wanted and did it, you got nothing.

Sounds awful, doesn’t it? Yet, this is exactly the situation that many dogs face throughout their lives. The reality is that we do control pretty much everything in our dogs’ lives. We decide when they eat (and what they eat and how much they eat), we decide when they get to go for a walk (and where they walk and for how long they walk), we decide whether they get to meet other dogs and people, we decided when to play with them, when or if to train and work with them, what toys they can have and where they can sleep. We even control when they have access to us and our homes and for how long. Every aspect of their lives is under our control. So how do we ensure that our dogs do not feel helpless, frustrated, stressed or depressed? Well, we need to give them back control by opening the lines of communication and allowing them to show us what they want and need.

Modern dog training focuses far more on encouraging dogs to be active participants in the training process, by reinforcing them for engaging with us, for offering behaviours, for problem solving and trying new things. This is a very different approach to traditional training, where a dog was expected to do nothing until cued and any initiative shown by the dog was frowned upon. In this sense, by making the dog an active role player in training, we are giving them back some control over the training process and allowing the dog to guide us as to how quickly we can progress from one step to the next. They are able to initiate exercises and, while we may set the environment up to encourage them to perform a certain behaviour, in many cases, from the dog’s perspective they are choosing what to do and figuring it out for themselves. As a result, the level of engagement and enthusiasm we see in dogs in our classes these days is huge in comparison to more traditional schools, even where positive reinforcement is used, but where the dogs are expected to do nothing until they are told what to do.

But it is not just in training that we need to consider allowing our dogs to have more control. We need to consider how we can give our dogs back some control over their everyday needs. We should be aware of what our dogs are asking for and we should be willing and ready to help them. Rosie and Cruz have many ways of asking for things:

1. Rosie will paw the bed, when she wants to get on – she doesn’t need help getting up, but seems to want encouragement, so I say: “Good Girl, up you go!” and she will spring up and settle down.
2. Cruz will stand and stare at the water bucket and then look back at us – this means the water is not fresh enough and he wants us to fill it up.
3. Rosie will moan just a little if Cruz is lying in the way and she can’t get past – she will look at him and look at me and make little noises. She is asking me to ask Cruz to move slightly so she can come through.
4. Late in the afternoon, I usually start getting stared at – this means that supper time is nigh!
5. Both dogs will go stand at the door to go out.
6. Cruz will go to and scratch on our bedroom door at night (which is open), if he wants to get back on the bed with us, but it is too dark for him to see where he is going to land – he wants us to switch on the light so he can see what he is doing.
7. Every morning, Cruz does a little dance that ends in a curtsy (bow) or rest (putting his chin on the ground), because he wants us to get a ball off the bookshelf, to start the day off right.
8. Every time Rosie comes inside after going to the toilet, she runs and stares at the biscuit tin, because she wants a biscuit.
9. Cruz will stare at the “chew” tin where I keep sinews when he is in the mood for something to chew.
10. In the evening, Rosie will paw the pillows on the dog couch, so we can move them so she has space to get up.

We generally respond to all these requests from our dogs. They are not unreasonable requests and they are all for things that make their lives comfortable and cause us no harm whatsoever. These little things help our dogs to have some control over the good things in their lives and keep them willing to communicate and engage with us. The key is to identify subtle and polite cues from your dog and respond to those, before they become less subtle and possibly inappropriate. I am sure that many dogs “demand” bark, because it is the only thing they have found that is annoying enough to actually get a response from their humans. Every other subtle signal is ignored and barking becomes the only successful option. If you want to avoid having a dog that barks to get you to listen, start looking for other ways your dog may be communicating their needs and responding to those.

These days we like to claim that our dogs are our partners and not our slaves, so why should we be the only ones ever allowed to ask for anything? Our dogs should be able to ask for things. If we allow them to do so, we can give them back some of the control that we have over their lives and make an enormous contribution to their emotional wellbeing.

Photo: Cruz doing his best "Please can I have my ball" curtsy 🥰

19/08/2026

Our beautiful Monday Advanced Class working on their loose lead or off lead walking - they are such a lovely, clever lot 🐾😎💞
No chokes, no pinch, no head collars - just fun and encouragement - and look at those happy tails 🥰

You don't need to try out aversive tools to understand how they work and why they're harmful.I saw a post today which cl...
16/08/2026

You don't need to try out aversive tools to understand how they work and why they're harmful.

I saw a post today which claimed that we are teaching training and behaviour students ideology rather than real education. That we are deciding what should and shouldn't be used in dog training and behaviour modification and passing that on to new students in the field, without allowing them to experience other options for themselves. That we are pretending that things like punishment and negative reinforcement don't exist and robbing those on the journey to becoming dog training professionals of a proper education.

I'm not sure who is supposedly doing this, but I formally taught behaviour and training for many years and we certainly did teach students about all types of learning. No one pretended to live in some fantasy land where punishment and aversives didn't exist.

Of course we taught students about them - but of course we also taught students about the potential fallout of positive punishment, negative reinforcement and even negative punishment. We had to teach them about all of these things, because our students learned how learning takes place in the brain itself, the emotional drivers of behaviour and the emotional consequences of training and behaviour modification techniques. Any decent and comprehensive education in behaviour and training has to cover all of this in order to create a proper understanding of the science behind learning and behaviour.

And any student with a handful of functioning brain cells, a modicum of common sense and an ounce of compassion or empathy will immediately recognise the harms that result from using positive punishment, negative reinforcement and aversive tools as your go-to training method.

Do teachers or child psychologists get to practice slapping children or shocking them with graduated electronic devices (yes, this used to be done) to "get the feel" for how these things work and decide for themselves whether it's okay or not okay to use them?

Well then....

Address

Kommetjie
Cape Town
7975

Opening Hours

Monday 08:30 - 17:00
Tuesday 08:30 - 17:00
Wednesday 08:30 - 17:00
Friday 08:30 - 17:00
Saturday 08:30 - 17:00

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Kommetjie Canine College posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Kommetjie Canine College:

Shortcuts

Share

Category