The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

The Not Perfect Cookie Co. I don’t promise perfection, but I promise you DELICIOUS and beautifully decorated sugar cookies!

Adorable graduation cookies for a super sweet Lafayette Jeff grad who aspires to become a large-animal veterinarian. Con...
06/01/2026

Adorable graduation cookies for a super sweet Lafayette Jeff grad who aspires to become a large-animal veterinarian. Congratulations Lilah - go kick some butt at Depauw!

Classic Winnie the Pooh cookies for a sweet baby shower!
05/28/2026

Classic Winnie the Pooh cookies for a sweet baby shower!

🏁Happy Race Day!! 🏁 🏁
05/24/2026

🏁Happy Race Day!! 🏁

🏁

I can’t believe I never posted these!! One of my favorite first birthday themes - One Happy Camper! They turned out SOOO...
05/04/2026

I can’t believe I never posted these!! One of my favorite first birthday themes - One Happy Camper! They turned out SOOOOOOO CUTE!

Big congratulations to the team on their 2nd place finish at last week’s Little 500! What an amazing accomplishment!I w...
05/03/2026

Big congratulations to the team on their 2nd place finish at last week’s Little 500! What an amazing accomplishment!

I was so honored to make cookies for the ladies for the second year in a row!

I am teaming up with again for Teacher Appreciation Week! If you’re looking for a SWEET way to thank those special teac...
04/27/2026

I am teaming up with again for Teacher Appreciation Week! If you’re looking for a SWEET way to thank those special teachers, look no further. The Teacher Appreciation cookie pack includes two hand-decorated sugar cookies, beautifully boxed up and ready to gift - along with a gift certificate to West Lafayette’s best locally-owned coffee shop, Ghost Coffee Roaster!

Due to graduation season being my BUSIEST time of year, only a limited quantity will be available, so please order early to ensure your order. The boxed set is $10 + your gift certificate amount ($5, $10, $15, and $20 increments available). Please DM to order by Friday, May 1. Cookie packs must be picked up Tuesday, May 5 or Wednesday, May 6.

Thank you for supporting your teachers, plus two locally-owned small businesses (from the Lafayette Jeff class of ‘99!) ❤️❤️

A very happy 3rd birthday to twins Marshall & Walter! Dino cookies for the win!
04/24/2026

A very happy 3rd birthday to twins Marshall & Walter! Dino cookies for the win!

Cute packaging makes even simple cookies look absolutely amazing! Baseball cookies with Grant’s real signature printed o...
04/19/2026

Cute packaging makes even simple cookies look absolutely amazing! Baseball cookies with Grant’s real signature printed on them, packaged inside a custom printed baseball mitt - so cute!

Super cute baseball themed baby shower cookies! ❤️💙❤️💙 ̇es
04/09/2026

Super cute baseball themed baby shower cookies! ❤️💙❤️💙

̇es

I hope Alden had THE BEST 9th birthday!
03/25/2026

I hope Alden had THE BEST 9th birthday!

Address

Cedar Lane
Lafayette, IN
47905

Telephone

+17655862848

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Not Perfect Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Not Perfect Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share