10/11/2026
This morning, it happened again, for what seems like the millionth time.
I received an enquiry from a pet guardian who had already sought professional help for their dog's behaviour. They had consulted a trainer or someone presenting themselves as a behaviourist, and the advice they received was essentially...to do more training.
It's a conversation I have far too often and I find myself increasingly concerned (especially here in South Africa) about how readily behavioural problems are approached as training problems, without sufficient consideration of the pet's emotional, physical and environmental needs.
It is simple. Teaching an animal what to do is not the same as understanding why they are behaving in a particular way.
Let me be clear: I have enormous respect for skilled, ethical animal trainers. I am a certified animal trainer myself and I know first hand that great training can improve communication, build confidence, provide opportunities for learning, and support a pet's emotional wellbeing.
However, there is an important distinction between teaching skills and assessing complex behavioural concerns.
A dog who barks and lunges at other dogs may be experiencing fear, frustration, pain, or a combination of contributing factors. A dog who panics when left alone does not need better obedience; they may be experiencing significant separation-related distress. A cat who suddenly starts urinating outside the litter box may have an underlying medical condition, be experiencing social conflict, or be struggling with aspects of their environment.
These behaviours are not simply problems to be corrected. They are information that needs to be understood.
This is where professional competence and scope of practice become critically important.
Being an experienced dog trainer does not automatically make someone qualified to assess complex behavioural disorders. Equally, calling oneself a behaviourist does not, in itself, demonstrate the education, clinical knowledge or competencies required to investigate them.
Behavioural assessment requires an understanding of learning theory, ethology, emotional and motivational systems, behavioural development, medical and pain-related influences, and the complex interactions between an animal and their environment.
It also requires recognising what we do not know.
There is nothing unprofessional about referring a case to someone with more specialised expertise. Quite the opposite. Recognising the limits of one's competence is an essential part of ethical professional practice.
What concerns me is when a pet's behaviour is interpreted as a failure of training before the possibility of fear, anxiety, pain, stress, frustration, illness or other underlying factors has been adequately explored and the consequences can be significant.
An individual may continue experiencing distress that goes unrecognised. Repeated exposure to situations they find frightening may exacerbate their difficulties. Medical conditions may remain undiagnosed. And guardians may invest considerable time, money and emotional energy into interventions that do not address the underlying problem.
Eventually, they may begin to believe that their dog or cat is simply difficult, stubborn or incapable of learning. Or worse, that they themselves have failed.
In reality, the problem may never have been properly identified.
Effective behavioural care requires a collaborative, multimodal approach. Veterinary assessment, environmental management, behaviour modification, and, where indicated, medication prescribed by a veterinarian may all have important roles to play.
These are not competing approaches. They are complementary parts of supporting a pet's overall welfare.
I often wonder how different things might be for some of the pets I meet if, instead of immediately asking, "How do we stop this behaviour?", someone had first asked, "What might this individual be experiencing, and why?"
That shift in perspective is fundamental to how I approach behaviour work.
Our responsibility should far extend beyond making pets easier to live with. It should include understanding their emotional experiences, recognising their physical and psychological needs, and ensuring that the interventions we recommend genuinely support their welfare.
Before we ask a pet to change their behaviour, we should first make an effort to understand what that behaviour is telling us.