The Tales That Really Matter

The Tales That Really Matter Tolkien blogger with a special fondness for the wider lore, and for Morfydd Clark, our Galadriel. Hi everyone!

I I'll be using this to promote the kittens I foster through AHHS here at Lafayette in the hopes of being able to find them their forever homes.

06/26/2026

Arondir and the Sindarin Tradition of Loyalty šŸƒ

Arondir’s decision to remain with the Southlanders, even when they have been abandoned by nearly everyone else, reflects a quality often associated with the Sindar in Tolkien’s writings: a deep attachment to the lands and peoples of Middle-earth.

ā€œThe Sindar… had love of the dark forests of Middle-earth, and the folk that lived there.ā€ — The Silmarillion, ā€œOf the Sindarā€

Unlike many of the High Elves who dwelt in great kingdoms, the Sindar and the Silvan Elves often lived close to the forests of Middle-earth and maintained enduring relationships with the lands they inhabited. Throughout Tolkien’s legendarium, they are frequently portrayed as protectors of their realms and steadfast allies of those who dwell nearby.

Tolkien also described what the Elves represent within his mythology:

ā€œThe Elves represent, as it were, the artistic, aesthetic, and purely scientific aspects of human nature raised to a higher level than is actually seen in Men.ā€ — The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 131 to Milton Waldman (c. 1951)

While Arondir is an original character created for The Rings of Power, his unwavering loyalty to the Southlanders recalls this longstanding tradition of Elves who choose to remain in Middle-earth and defend the places—and the people—they have come to love. šŸ¤“

Happy World Beatles Day, by the way 😊 This is as good a time as any to remind you all that Morfydd Clark, our Galadriel,...
06/25/2026

Happy World Beatles Day, by the way 😊 This is as good a time as any to remind you all that Morfydd Clark, our Galadriel, will be playing Cynthia Lennon in Sam Mendes' upcoming 4-part biopic 🄹🄰🄲 Filming has just wrapped in Spain and has moved to Great Britain.

Happy birthday to our beloved Princess Disa, Sophia Nomvete! An original character to the show, Disa has truly become a ...
06/24/2026

Happy birthday to our beloved Princess Disa, Sophia Nomvete! An original character to the show, Disa has truly become a fan favorite and a perfect illustration of the best of Tolkien's dwarves, in some ways even better than some of Peter Jackson's choices. Disa is one of the pillars of the show, especially in Season 2, and you, Sophia, have portrayed her to perfection. Have a great day with your loved ones, and we will look forward to seeing you show us Disa's continuing story 😊 🄳

Happy belated Birthday to our High King Gil-galad, Benjamin Walker. What a transformation you've undergone these past tw...
06/22/2026

Happy belated Birthday to our High King Gil-galad, Benjamin Walker. What a transformation you've undergone these past two seasons from a machiavellian politician to a selfless warrior king, and yet one that absolutely makes sense given the story and your great performance. We know how your story will eventually end, but we will be there with you until it does. šŸ§ā€ā™‚ļø šŸ’

"And now at great length is that great fest of Tarnin Austa or the Gates of Summer near at hand. For know that on that n...
06/21/2026

"And now at great length is that great fest of Tarnin Austa or the Gates of Summer near at hand. For know that on that night it was their custom to begin a solemn ceremony at midnight, continuing it even until the dawn of Tarnin Austa broke, and no voice was uttered in the city from midnight until the break of day, but the dawn they hailed with ancient songs."--The Book of Lost Tales

Morfydd Clark, our Galadriel, in a lovely red summer dress that she wore for the Victoria and Albert Museum's Summer Party on June 19, 2024, in honor of the Summer Solstice and the official start of summer.

🄹🄲🄰
06/19/2026

🄹🄲🄰

ā€œPistols cracked, sabers flashed, and with blood-curdling yells the French horsemen gathered themselves to overwhelm the...
06/18/2026

ā€œPistols cracked, sabers flashed, and with blood-curdling yells the French horsemen gathered themselves to overwhelm the enemy…Next moment volleys of musketry lashed men and horses at close range with a fiery hail; horses crashed on their riders, riders toppled and reeled, riderless horses plunging into the melee to increase the disorder. Wellington’s veterans had not fought for five years through the Peninsula for nothingā€¦ā€ā€”Elizabeth, Countess of Longford, "Wellington: The Years of the Sword"

06/17/2026

Two things can be true at the same time. LOTR IS a "fundamentally religious and Catholic work", as Tolkien himself put it. But it's also "unconsciously so" and this is the big difference between Tolkien and say CS Lewis. Tolkien isn't trying to preach. He's trying to express who he is in his writing. And who he is is somebody who believes in various universal truths and ideals, which he believed reach their source and summit in Catholicism but he wasn't interested in forcing people to agree with him.

06/17/2026

Ordinarily I wouldn't share AI slop that isn't honest about what it is, but in this case...I honestly think it's hilarious, and such an incredible self-burn, how this is being claimed as a better adaptation than Rings of Power even while the AI itself is so soulless and unoriginal that it had to mine RoP for material. That speaks both to the artistic poverty of so many of RoP's critics, and the heart and passion that actually did go into Rings of Power.

Some thoughts on Anya Taylor-Joy joining The Hunt for Gollum as a Sindarin Elven ranger called Seren:—I'm not as familia...
06/16/2026

Some thoughts on Anya Taylor-Joy joining The Hunt for Gollum as a Sindarin Elven ranger called Seren:
—I'm not as familiar with Anya as I am with other actresses, but I've liked what I've seen so far, and I'm looking forward to seeing her in Dune 3. Good luck to her as she joins Hunt for Gollum.
—Given how her character has been described (Variety calls her "a Sindar Elf of the Woodland Realm, who is described as ā€˜a trusted and lethal agent of King Thranduil.ā€™ā€), she feels less like her own character and more like a substitute for Legolas (probably not appearing, and thank goodness, Orlando hasn’t gotten any younger since the Hobbit movies where Bard the Bowman looked more Elven than Legolas) and a surrogate for Thranduil (given how his name was listed in the original cast announcement in April, ā€œWith Lee Pace as Thranduilā€, Lee is almost definitely going to be a cameo; after all, Elijah’s name was listed the same way and he confirmed to Collider a couple of weeks ago that he’s just in a scene or two).
—Almost certainly, Anya is going to get an undeserved amount of hate just for being a girl, an active and warlike participant, and an original character. Unfortunately, because she’s in a movie that’s part of the ā€œPeter Jackson universeā€ she’s also going to get a lot of praise from people who won’t extend a similar grace to Rings of Power’s warrior Nerwen and beautifully Tolkienian OC Arondir. That’s not a mark against Anya, she can’t help some fans (including some pretty big and important ones) being close-minded. But it’s a fact, and I don’t like it.
—None of my larger issues with that movie have been redressed. See my essay ā€œThe Hunt for Nostalgiaā€ for details.

Address

224 Beaver Run Lane
Williamston, SC
29697

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Tales That Really Matter posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share