11/11/2026
LET’S TALK ABOUT THE QUITTERS & CULLS.
One of the most important conversations we can have in the working Patterdale Terrier community is also one of the conversations people seem most uncomfortable having.
The quitters. The dogs that didn’t make the cut. The dogs that simply did not possess what we expect from a working terrier.
We spend an enormous amount of time celebrating the great ones. We share pictures, videos, pedigrees, accomplishments, and stories about dogs that have proven themselves in the field. And rightfully so. Those dogs deserve recognition.
But what about the ones that didn’t make it?
I would argue that documenting the failures in a working bloodline is every bit as important, if not MORE important, than documenting its successes.
Here’s why.
The responsibility of a working dog breeder isn’t simply to produce another great dog. It’s to consistently produce working dogs generation after generation. To accomplish that, we have to understand not only what works within our bloodlines, but also what doesn’t.
A dog that consistently lacks the desire to work, quits when the pressure becomes too much, or simply doesn’t possess the characteristics necessary to perform its intended job provides us with valuable information.
That information should not be hidden. It should be studied, documented, and taken into consideration when making future breeding decisions.
The greatest danger to a working breed isn’t necessarily producing a quitter to a cull. It’s producing one and refusing to acknowledge it. Refusing to share that information.
Every bloodline and or breeder has produced dogs that didn’t make the cut. Every single one. Me included.
The difference is what we choose to do with that information. As well as how we respond to that information.
And there’s another aspect of this conversation I believe deserves serious attention.
The rush to get to a terrier once it’s located its quarry underground.
Something I’ve noticed over the years is how quickly some individuals seem determined to reach their dogs. There’s a difference between digging efficiently and digging with an unnecessary sense of urgency throwing the methods of proper terrier digging out the window. Of course, the safety and welfare of the terrier must always come first, and circumstances can require immediate intervention. But I do wonder how much our modern practices influence what we consider a great working dog.
If we’re describing a terrier as a solid, dependable worker, shouldn’t we be evaluating its ability to remain consistent throughout the work, rather than simply its willingness to engage initially?
Our brothers across the pond have long emphasized a traditional principle of terrier work: one hole, one dog, one quarry, with the dog and quarry dug to together and a whole that is as wide as it is deep. This is all part of the standard for this breed. Again the work is the standard.
That standard of working and evaluating terriers raises an uncomfortable question.
How many of today’s so-called “great dogs” would actually make the cut if evaluated consistently under the same expectations?
How many reputations have been built around dogs whose limitations were never fully understood or openly discussed?
I’m not asking these questions to discredit anyone’s dogs. I’m asking because if we genuinely care about preserving working ability, then our standards of evaluation must be as honest as our breeding records.
A dog’s reputation should never be more important than the truth about its performance. And no traditional practice should take priority over the welfare of the dog or quarry.
When breeders refuse to acknowledge the shortcomings within their own bloodlines, they create a false picture of what those genetics consistently produce. Other breeders make decisions based on incomplete information. Puppies get placed in working homes with expectations they may never fulfill. Undesirable characteristics continue being passed through generations because nobody wanted to have an uncomfortable conversation. There are dogs out there right now being bred that are subpart or culls themselves and come from a dog that was a cull who also came from parents that were culls.
Ultimately, it’s the dogs and the future of the breed that pay the price.
And perhaps one of the saddest parts of this entire subject is how personal people make it.
I’ve seen friendships damaged, relationships destroyed, and people fall out simply because someone acknowledged that a particular dog didn’t make the cut. I have had people dislike me before simply because I pointed out a cull that my dogs produced that was being bred. Ironically enough we now find out that same individual had to cull the exact dog that he took such big offense to hearing that the mother was a cull. But not after the dog was almost “accidentally bred to” which seems to happen far too often on that side. I’ve had one accidental breeding in 20 years of breeding dogs.
Think about that.
We’re willing to lose friendships or mistreat others over information that could help preserve the very working characteristics we all claim to value.
And this is where I want to acknowledge something I genuinely value about some of the relationships I’ve built in these dogs.
Gentlemen like Mr. Craver, Mr Dailey, Mr Ashlock, Mr. Murdoch and many other friends of mine are people I can sit down with and have completely open conversations about the dogs that didn’t make the cut. And it’s a slight to no one.
We can discuss dogs they’ve produced that quit. Dogs I’ve produced that quit. Descendants of our dogs that have quit. Dogs belonging to other breeders that have quit. We can discuss how why and when they quit. It doesn’t matter whose name is on the pedigree or whose yard the dog came out of.
We can discuss all of it without the conversation turning into animosity, damaged friendships, or some perceived attack on someone’s ego.
And I place tremendous value on that.
In my opinion, these are the kinds of men who produce some of the finest families of working dogs. Not because every dog they produce is exceptional, but because they’re willing to be brutally honest about the ones that aren’t.
They understand that a dog’s actions are not a personal reflection of their worth as men or breeders.
A dog quitting doesn’t make its breeder a failure. But a breeder refusing to acknowledge that dog quit can become a failure of responsibility.
There is an enormous difference.
When you can have these conversations without worrying about bruising someone’s ego, you can actually learn something. You can identify patterns, recognize weaknesses, make better breeding decisions, and move your family of dogs forward.
That kind of honesty is something I respect tremendously, and I believe it’s one of the defining characteristics of a truly serious working dog breeder.
We need more of those conversations, not fewer.
A dog failing to meet the working standard is not a personal attack on its breeder, its owner, or its bloodline. It’s information.
And we need that information.
We also need to be fair in how we evaluate it. Not every dog that fails in one situation is genetically lacking. Poor handling, insufficient opportunity, immaturity, injury, and other circumstances can affect performance. There is a difference between a dog that has never been given a fair opportunity and one that has repeatedly demonstrated it simply doesn’t possess the qualities we’re looking for. But if the conversations are not help these understandings are forever lost.
That’s why honest documentation matters.
As breeders, we should be recording the dogs that excel, the dogs that are average, and the dogs that fail to demonstrate the working qualities we’re trying to preserve.
We should be asking questions about littermates, parents, grandparents, and offspring. Not just how many great dogs a particular stud produced, but how many didn’t make the cut.
Ten great workers out of twelve offspring tells us something very different from ten great workers out of a hundred.
And yet, too often, we only hear about the ten.
If we are serious about preserving the working Patterdale Terrier, identifying individuals that lack the necessary working characteristics and removing them from breeding consideration must be one of our priorities.
That doesn’t mean those dogs have no value or don’t deserve good homes. It means they shouldn’t be used to reproduce the very characteristics we’re trying to eliminate.
We cannot selectively breed for working ability if we refuse to acknowledge the absence of it.
Going forward, I’d like to see more transparency among working terrier breeders. More honest conversations about what different bloodlines produce. More willingness to acknowledge shortcomings without treating every criticism as an insult.
Talking about the dogs that didn’t make the cut is not damaging to the breed. Refusing to talk about them is.
A breeder who can tell you about the failures in their bloodline is giving you information that may be far more valuable than another story about their greatest dog or successful dig.
And personally, I’d be far more cautious about acquiring a puppy from someone who claims their bloodline doesn’t produce quitters than from someone who openly discusses the ones that didn’t make it.
Because the breeder who knows where the weaknesses are has an opportunity to improve.
The breeder who refuses to acknowledge them will continue breeding blindly.
We owe it to the dogs that came before us, the dogs we’re producing today, and the working terriers that will exist long after we’re gone to tell the whole story.
Not just the champions. Not just the famous producers. Not just the dogs that made us proud.
The quitters and culls, too.
If we’re truly here for the preservation of the working Patterdale Terrier, then these conversations shouldn’t divide us. They should make us better breeders, better sportsmen, and better stewards of the breed.
The work is the standard. And honesty about the work is how we preserve it.
Pictured: The dog in the forefront “Neil” (named latter in life) started out decent but proved to not make the grade with close friends of ours (which is why she wasn’t named before leaving) and she failed on several individuals yards to make the grade but was sadly bred to a couple times which produced more pups that proved to not make the grade on their owner’s yards. Later we heard stories of her being a great dog but could never get a single photo of the dog at work. More likely is she was bred and pups peddled because she comes from blood that many people want. The dog in the background was her mother and her name was DC. DC was as close to Deadgame as a living dog could possibly be. She produced some excellent working stock as I keep several sons and daughters of her to this day. As always we keep what works and remove what fails without much hassle.