22/08/2026
Let's talk transparency vs honesty and health guarantees vs support for puppy owners.
They may seem like the same things, but if you've been in the dog world long enough you will come to realize the significant difference between them, probably in a really unfortunate way.
Honesty means telling the truth when someone asks you a question. Transparency means sharing the truth and important details before anyone has to ask. A health guarantee often guarantees things a breeder can't possibly guarantee (like hips or elbows), and requires a puppy to be returned for a replacement, where people generally don't want to give up their dog and want support and to know things have been done to help make sure it won't lead to financial ruin and heartbreak.
Here are a couple situations with the same concern, where one breeder is transparent and the other is honest and where one breeder has a guarantee and one has a policy for how they provide support as an example.
A) Two people co-own a bitch who produced a litter of puppies:
A1) You are interested in the litter and ask all your questions that you can think of, and the breeder you speak with is honest and answers all the questions truthfully. You purchase a puppy and take it home and then find out that the puppy has littermates who are deaf when the co-breeder is tagged in a photo. This is not a common occurrence in the breed so you didn't think to ask, and you now wonder if your puppy can hear. When you ask the breeder about this they do tell you that the litter had deaf puppies in it but your puppy was BAER tested and can hear normally
A2) You are interested in the litter and ask all your questions that you can think of, and the breeder you speak with is honest and answers all the questions truthfully. They also tell you that the litter was BAER tested because there were concerns about deafness in the litter, which is uncommon but not unheard of because the pattern the breed is can come with deafness like dalmatians, parti colored cockers, etc. The puppy you are discussing has normal hearing, but they want you to be aware of it before deciding. You still purchase the puppy and take it home.
B) You reach out to a breeder with a planned litter.
B1) You are interested in the litter and ask all your questions that you can think of, and the breeder you speak with is honest and answers all the questions truthfully. The dam and sire are both fully health tested and have CHIC numbers. You buy the puppy and take it home, and see that on OFA there is a pennhip listed that is above (worse than) breed average and worry until your dog is 2 whether they will pass OFA hips or develop osteoarthritis from hip joint incongruity, and if you have to return your dog if they don't pass because the breeders guarantee requires return of the dog for a replacement.
B2) You are interested in the litter and ask all your questions that you can think of, and the breeder you speak with is honest and answers all the questions truthfully. The breeder tells you the specific health test results, noting that the dam had passed OFA hips with a fair rating, and had a higher than breed average pennhip score meaning that their hips had more laxity but they specifically are breeding her to this dog because his pennhip was significantly better than breed average. They tell you that they can not guarantee hips or elbows because they are so dependent on so many factors, but they are doing their best to improve what they have and support their puppy people. They also say that if you do pennhip (after 4 months) or OFA hips (24 months) and post them publicly on the OFA database AND have insurance on the puppy they will pay up to $X toward those x-rays so you can screen early, and can forego the added financial burden (because of insurance) to be able to support the dog you love however you need. The breeder will take the dog back, but they feel like people love their dog at 2 years old and just want support, not to give the dog back for money back or a replacement. You buy the puppy and take it home.
In each of these situations the breeder was honest, but is honesty the best policy? Shouldn't we expect transparency? Shouldn't we expect support? Shouldn't we be in this together for the dogs and their owners trying to make sure they all live the best lives they can together?