10/22/2026
If there were ever a topic where I wish I could snap my fingers and reframe it for anyone who is struggling, it's the herdbound horse.
In my world, that's just a horse. We label it because the natural instinct to be with one's friends is inconvenient for us in many ways, and it can lead to what we then call "behavioral problems."
In my world, that's just a horse being a horse.
When we understand what makes a horse a horse and not a dog or a cat or a ladybug or a flying squirrel, it becomes a lot easier to address the things about the horse that can be issues if we don't teach them another way of being. This didn't get talked about when I was a kid in 4-H or Pony Club: we learned the anatomy of the horse, we learned about different types of bits, we learned how to groom and pick a hoof and post on the correct diagonal. But no one ever taught me what actually makes a horse what they are and how to help them feel better in the world we create for them. I had to go figure that out later.
A horse is first and foremost a prey animal, and as a prey animal they are constantly adjusting to the pressures of the world around them in order to return to a state of inner peace. A prey animal has an innate fear response because they know they are a prey animal in the same way a wolf or a grizzly bear knows it's a predator. If something is suspicious or concerning, a horse isn't going to wait around to figure out if it's going to be a problem: they are going to do what comes naturally to them, and that is move their feet and leave, creating distance between themselves and the thing of concern until they feel more secure. At that point they might turn around and have a look at the thing and decide if it's still a problem or not, but safety comes first, always.
The other way the horse maintains safety is in numbers. Many eyes in many heads can watch the environment better than an individual can, and the whole herd can act as an emotional barometer for danger. If one individual senses a problem, the group can respond together.
So if you have a horse who exhibits anxiety when removed from other horses, you have a horse who is acting like a normal horse acts.
If you don't do anything to address the anxiety so the horse learns he can be safe without being in the direct presence of other horses, you're asking the horse over and over and over to entertain situations in which he lacks security. Labeling what the horse does in these situations as "behavioral problems" is convenient for us because it puts the onus on the horse instead of us.
The default suggestion given when one has a horse that expresses what we typically refer to as "herdbound" or "buddy sour" behaviors is to work them, and work them hard. Make them move their feet. Don't let them rest by their friends. Work them hard enough that they ask for a break, and then only let them do so away from the other horses. I'm not going to tell you this can't work. I will argue it is far more nuanced than repeated sweaty saddle pads, that it is often applied incorrectly, and that without proper understanding this is pretty miserable and cruel to the horse. A horse that is anxious and feeling insecure ALREADY feels miserable - he doesn't need help feeling worse. He needs help feeling better.
You can harness the power of allowing the anxious horse to move his feet in such a way that you begin to engage his mind. When you begin to engage his mind, the horse starts to become more present in his own body. When he becomes more present in his own body, his thoughts come to where he is and not where he would prefer to be. When his thoughts come to where he is, you now have a chance to show him he can be safe when he is settled and here, with you.
If I were a pageant queen - and it’s a good bet I’m not, given how many of my "nice" clothes have seen the inside of a barn - this would be my “world peace”: no horse labeled a problem for doing exactly what horses do, and every one of them shown how to feel safe where they stand.
Pictured: Lewis being a very good student after helping Carl Bledsoe demo some groundwork.