01/16/2020
Finding Your Dog’s Currency
How do you motivate a dog to learn? You “pay” him with something he wants. That thing that he wants is his “currency.”
A tidbit of food is a type of currency that many dogs recognize and accept, and a lot of trainers use a bit of cheese or a piece of dried liver to motivate their pupils. But many other kinds of currencies are available as well. For some dogs, an effective currency might be an opportunity to play with a tennis ball or a tug toy. For others, an effective currency might be petting and praise. Sometimes, a dog’s reward can be the simple pleasure he gets out of a job well done. Consider, for example, a member of a retrieving breed who just loves to bring back a thrown object or a downed bird, or the assertive member of a breed noted for police work who gets to bite the padded arm of a person during protection training.
No matter what currency you find works best with your dog, I recommend sticking with that currency and not switching among several with the same dog. You can use praise alone as a currency, and praise can be combined with almost any other currency, such as toys or treats. But I would not mix use of toys and treats together with the same dog, for example. I would use one or the other, because that provides consistency for the dog, and adds value to the currency as well.
While many dogs recognize and accept food as a currency, in many cases a trainer can find a better motivator than food, depending on the dog. Yes, you can teach a dog to sit by using cheese. The method does work. But keep this in mind: The quality of the effort you get from a dog often depends on the type of motivator that drives him to perform the work. You often get better performance from an animal that desires to please – and to receive approval from – its leader. These desires spring directly from a canine’s instinctive need to belong to a pack.
How can you best determine the optimum method to use with your dog? You can begin by considering the natural tendencies of the particular type of dog with which you are dealing. Is your dog a type of hound? Is it an assertive type of canine that might be used for personal protection? Is it a herding dog? A retriever? If it’s a mixed breed, what do you think might be the combination of heritages from which it springs?
Dogs are highly individual creatures, just like people, so it is foolish to paint with too broad a brush. We often find exceptions to the general rule. Still, an assessment of your dog’s breed (or its primary breeds in the case of a mixed-breed animal) is a good place to start in trying to determine effective currency, and you need to be willing to be flexible in your approach. While I’m not a devoted fan of using only food incentives, for example, some types of dogs – such as hounds – sometimes do comparatively well with them, so food might be a good place to start in trying to find a currency that will work for your beagle.
A hound, by the way, is a dog – usually with long, floppy ears – that often makes its living tracking other animals by means of a scent trail that animal has laid down on the ground (as opposed to scent that is pulled from the air). These types of hounds have many hundreds of thousands more scent receptors in their heads than do most other types of canines, and the most important thing in a hound’s world tends to be its olfactory system. Scent-trailing hounds tend to be less concerned than other dogs about obedience tasks and more concerned about what they smell or taste. This does not make them “bad” dogs. They simply are bred to operate with different priorities than, let us say, herding dogs.
Canines with a tendency toward high prey drive (the desire to chase things that move), such as a Doberman pinscher or a Rottweiler, for example, often will work hard for an opportunity to chase a tennis ball.
Working and herding dogs, such as Australian herding dogs or German shepherd dogs, tend to have a tremendous willingness to please their owner or handler. A show of approval from that person often is a very adequate and effective currency.
Your Labrador retriever might work for the same kind of reward, or he might work even better for an opportunity to chase a ball or a stick.
Having considered all of these factors, then, how does a trainer determine the best currency to use with a particular dog? He does it by observation, followed by trial and error. Does your dog trip over his own feet to get to you to (1) get to that cheese that you have in your pocket or to (2) get to that tennis ball you have in your hand or to (3) just get to be with you and bask in your presence? You determine this by observation and interaction. And you create simple tests involving all of the possible currencies, and then observe your dog’s reactions.