10/28/2026
Here is an interesting post about judging! Judging takes you places!!
Don’t forget-our horse judging clinic is this Saturday!
Sign up at 4H online, message us or text Anne at 810-272-6435!!
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1DmZ1wSoJq/?mibextid=wwXIfr
Dairy judging – and any form of livestock judging – is hard to understand if you’ve never been a part of it. Evaluating animals and walking in circles while practicing your reasons may, in fact, be questioned by outsiders. It’s a great reminder to talk about WHY we judge and encourage the next generation to do so.
Last week I helped officiate the Dairy Evaluation CDE at the National FFA Organization's Convention. FFA members from across the nation looked at six classes of four dairy animals to rank them on a scorecard that includes dairy strength, mammary, feet & legs, etc. There were three classes of heifers (cattle who had not calved yet) and three classes of milking cows that contestants were expected to give oral reasons defending their placing. The practical outcome is being able to evaluate animals - essential to breeding and management.
But the REAL VALUE of judging has little to do with that. You see, judging hands over life lessons in decision-making, communications, persuasion, and critical thinking through real world competitions. I specifically recall standing in a room when I was 12 years old trying to explain why I thought the class should be placed a certain way – and failing. I left the room crying and wanted to quit dairy judging if it meant I had to ever give oral reasons again.
Fast forward to my final years of Michigan 4-H and at Michigan State University College of Agriculture and Natural Resources after I managed to struggle through reasons: dairy judging took me places I never dreamt of, competing in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, and Tennessee. It handed me some of my best memories with teammates and friends from other universities. While my ability to “see cattle” contributed to my first career stop in dairy genetics, it’s safe to say that the gift of persuasively communicating has done more for my career than any other skill.
That started with freezing pens not writing while looking at cows in practice, facing embarrassment while giving reasons (I'd still rather speak for 900 people than give reasons to 1), being coachable, overcoming my own fears, and walking in many circles practicing reasons. After coaching a lot of teams myself, I saw the same lessons handed down to 4-H and FFA members – there is magic to the process. And when my daughter competed in dairy judging, I became convinced she could argue wallpaper off the wall – a skill that’s still serving her in med school.
During the national contest at FFA, I watched hundreds of blue and gold jackets try to figure out which animal was 1, 2, 3, and 4 in a class. It reminded me that judging wasn’t really about that one day – or even the scores they received, in spite of the pressure every contestant felt. Rather, judging is more about the opportunities it affords in the future. I'm very thankful for all that judging gave me and am glad to give back in a small way in appreciation for those who poured into me.