06/03/2022
Everyone has been so deeply brainwashed that common sense, and the obvious, are exceptionally hard to find…while nonsense is plentiful.
I see posts like this, am tagged in posts like this, and have comments asking for help framed like this—daily. Everyone has been so completely, thoroughly, comprehensively programmed what is and isn’t acceptable/cutting-edge/scientific/humane—and are acutely aware of the social fallout if one deviates from the accepted (allowed) narrative—that it seems no one is able to think anymore. They simply follow the thought police, and they and their dog(s) suffer the consequences.
Today I was tagged in a post where a young GSD is disrespecting, bullying, and biting his owners, and they’re asking for advice and bringing a trainer on board. But nowhere in the long list of comments (from well-intentioned friends and the owners as well) did anyone mention simply punishing the behavior which is so problematic. And also mentioned in the comments: if the behavior doesn’t improve, the dog will be returned to the pound and put down. (Relaying the owner’s words.)
Folks, all the suggestions listed in the original graphic are perfectly solid additions, and could be extremely helpful AFTER first punishing the unwanted behavior. Then, and only then can you build/share all the other great stuff on top of the new foundation without negative fallout, or lack of success. But the “P” word is simply too in unacceptable, and so, the simple answers for this owner, and so many others will likely remain elusive and hidden. And the behavior will likely remain intact—and only worsen. And the outcome will likely be unpleasant.
PS, for all those who will reflexively respond that all the things mentioned in the original graphic could help take the edge off and make success more possible/more plausible, if you’re not going to acknowledge the sequence of how to properly deal with unwanted behavior—first stop it, and then build from there—and instead try to support the milder, kinder workaround so as to avoid discussing/using punishment, I’m sorry, but you’re part of the problem. This is the common dance of “enlightened” responses/thinkers. Ask yourself why stopping the behavior, resetting the relationship dynamics and creating a more healthy social dynamic FIRST isn’t your go-to. It’s telling. And what it’s telling isn’t good, nor healthy, nor helpful.