10/26/2026
So far, so bad for plant fibre. This week we have learned it:
DOESN'T PRODUCE GREATER BACTERIAL DIVERSITY
DOESN'T PRODUCE MORE SCFAs
DOESN'T REDUCE COLON CANCER
DOESN'T REDUCE IBD (likely exacerbates it in pets)
AGGRAVATES CONSTIPATION IN MOST
Now to the bit few like to talk about - the side effects of plant fibre in the carnivore digestive system.
Stool score is a key indicator of gut health.
Numerous studies show that raw or meat-fed dogs and cats have superior stool scores. That is a diet naturally lower in plant fibre.
Moreover, adding plant fibre to HEALTHY dogs and cats decreases their stool score. Not all the time mind, they can take a little bit, no doubt, but fibre supplements tend to have that effect on them so we need to be careful when using them.
(At this point, people want to add in the studies of diarrhetic pets. That's not what we're talking about here. Most pets have not got diarrhoea. Moreover, lots of things decrease diarrhoea - rice, glutamine, collagen, zinc, fasting, broth, electrolytes, etc.).
But the problems with plant fibre go much deeper than that.
Dogs and cats have carnivorous digestive systems. Short, fast, acidic, undeveloped caecums. They are rigged for digestion primarily and fermentation secondarily (and that biome appears to work best ferment protein, not plant fibre).
Most importantly, they have taurine-conjugated bile (omnivores have glycine-conjugated bile). This means, every time they digest, taurine is released with bile into the intestines. It's important for the dogs and cats taurine turn over that they recycle that taurine out and back into the body.
When you add plant fibre to their diet you mess with that process.
Beet pulp, a common ingredient used in kibble, normally makes up 2-5% of the product as it helps the too-easily-digested, refined carbohydrate product from gumming up the dog and cats digestive system.
Researchers tested what 4.7% beet pulp does to a dogs digestion and it was shown to reduce plasma taurine in dogs by 68% and lower whole-blood taurine by 44%. Further, it results in 7 percentage points less protein digestibility and 65% higher faecal bile-acid concentration. All four differences were statistically significant.
How much of a problem is this?
One marker is how much DCM is out there. Mc Cauley et al. (2020) estimate around 1% of America's dogs are living with DCM (900,000 animals). Cats unknown.
As the main cause is a lack of taurine, know that plant fibre is not welcome at the DCM party.
Then there's bloat. Inappropriate fermentation is driving the bloat epidemic in dogs. 3 studies point their finger at something in kibble. FD1 explained how the most likely culprit is soluble fibre as we know it drives gas production in dogs.
In a prospective study (where the dogs were followed) of 1,914 large and giant-breed dogs, Glickman et al. (2000) found that 105 experienced bloat with GDV. 30 of them died (giving a case mortality of 28.6%). They worked out the lifetime GDV mortality was approximately 7% in the breeds studied, rising to 13% in Great Danes. A 2020 study by Sharp et al. (2020) examined 498 dogs with confirmed GDV, representing more than 50 breeds, at Tufts University veterinary teaching hospital in Massachusetts. 36% of them died.
Staggering figures, considering the death afforded the poor animal.
So, to the above list, we can now add:
MORE FIBRE MEANS MORE GAS, INCREASING THE RISK OF BLOAT
INCREASING PLANT FIBRE REDUCES PROTEIN DIGESTION
FIBRE INTERRUPTS TAURINE RECYCLING IN MEAT EATERS
MORE FIBRE RESULTS IN POORER STOOL SCORES
It's not looking good for fibre as a whole, is it?
Summary post coming later for folk in a flutter, then I'll leave plant fibre alone to focus on more suitable fermenting substrates in the meat eater...!