12/21/2024
Training methods are not just a “difference of opinion”. They’re a matter of animal wellbeing and ethics.
In my recent posts, I’ve talked about how shelter dogs inherently experience a lot of stress in their lives and don’t often get their needs met.
On top of that, pain in dogs can go unnoticed in shelters since shelter dogs aren’t being supervised as much as dogs in homes might be, or undiagnosed due to limited resources.
Aversive control also very much removes much needed agency and opportunities to exhibit natural behaviours from dogs who already have so little choice and control in their lives.
In knowing this, subjecting dogs in rescues and shelters to aversive training tools and methods that cause pain, fear, and stress on dogs is detrimental to the dogs’ wellbeing, unethical, unnecessary, and counter-productive.
It is also dangerous for staff, volunteers, potential adopters, and the general public since it is well-documented that increased aggressive behaviours is a fallout of aversive and punishment-based methods. Exacerbating pain through aversive tools and methods on dogs already experiencing pain can also certainly lead to the display of aggressive behaviours.
Sure, there can be situations in shelters and rescues where emergency handling and tools like slipleashes may be needed. However, emergencies aren’t training, and slipleashes should be seen as a temporary safety measure, not a tool for punishing dogs and forcing them into compliance.
And understandably, trying to help dogs find homes asap is important, but finding adopters who prioritise a dog’s wellbeing over how well they comply out of fear is even more important.
It is no longer “rescuing” when the wellbeing of animals is not prioritised.
It is no longer “animal welfare” when needs-deprived animals are deliberately and unnecessarily subjected to more pain, fear, and stress.
As says: “If an animal rescue claims to care about animal welfare, but promotes the use of aversive training, then they actually don’t care about animal welfare.”
I hope in time we will see more rescues and shelters adopt humane and ethical care for dogs because shelter dogs deserve better.
ID: The text says “It should be a bare minimum for rescues to refrain from aversive tools and methods.” On the right is an old photo of Dave, a brown Singapore Special dog with pointy ears, sitting with his mouth slightly open.