Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc-  Equine Sanctuary Our rescue is currently full and only open to emergency animal control cases. please call 502-424-4987 for more information.

Misfit Toys Rescue Division is full service 501c3 equine rescue/sanctuary/retraining facility for problem horses, specializing in saddlebreds with behavioral issues. We will, however, help place your horses into homes if you can no longer keep them.

11/20/2026
11/20/2026

Hi! My name is Lexie! I'm a land walrus. I need a home or a sponsor.

And yes.... SIGH...IM ALREADY ON A DIET

11/20/2026

I love her evil self so much. ❤️

Hi everyone! I'm posting a list of horses who need sponsors for 2027:RosiePokeyToffee Calypso EasterJesseLexiePatrick- s...
11/20/2026

Hi everyone! I'm posting a list of horses who need sponsors for 2027:

Rosie
Pokey
Toffee
Calypso
Easter
Jesse
Lexie
Patrick- sponsored thru March
Dolly- sponsored thru March
Louie
Sugarberry
Alana- sponsored thru 2026 ❤️
Tiny Tim
Snoop
Breeze
Mori- sponsored thru November so far ❤️
Finn
Cliff sponsored ty auntie Laura
Kota sponsored ty Auntie Laura
Elton sponsored ty Auntie Laura

Thank you all so much! We have had some sponsors with medical emergencies recently and so a few of the horses are already a few months behind if anyone can assist with the shortage or any upcoming needs. Thank you so so so so much everyone! Each horse realistically uses $300 a month in resources but we cover most of their costs, leaving our sponsorships at $100 a month for full sponsorship on a regular horse and $150 a horse for those with special needs. We pride ourselves on being a mostly self funded rescue, but the help we do receive is very much appreciated and very much necessary to complete the needs of the horses. We can't take spectacular care without spectacular support, so we appreciate each and every one of you!

Please contact me to set up your monthly sponsorship payments today! All new full sponsors will receive a misfit Toys T-shirt and cookbook along with a photo and updates on their horse.

Pictured is Tiny Tim!

11/20/2026

Jesse doesn't understand. Eight years at the rescue. Stood up once again for someone to come look at him. 😭

11/19/2026

I love seeing my blind and delicate little sugar plums eating their second breakfast every day at ten am. It tickles my little black soul to see them inhaling all of my money. Seriously. ❤️🙌

11/19/2026

Hey subscribers! If you could compare your horse to a superhero, who would they be?

Happy hump day. Everyone!  It's turning cold out, and we need some winter assistance at the rescue! We are looking for: ...
11/18/2026

Happy hump day. Everyone! It's turning cold out, and we need some winter assistance at the rescue!

We are looking for:

68 -$35 round bale donors
6- $60 round bale donors
20- $50 round bale donors

We will be giving out second edition MTRD cookbooks with all donations $35 and up! Please add your address in the comment/memo section of your donation!

The hay should cover us through December if we can secure it immediately. We already acquired and put the $60 bales in the fields already. Please help if able!

Please give a horse a home.or sponsor one if able. If you cannot donate, please share, comment, and like our page and our posts. It all helps to feed the horses ❤️

Misfithorsetoys.org

Kill Pen Schemes hurt ALL Horse.Say it with me, so you don't get dupod into thinking you're helping while you're actuall...
11/18/2026

Kill Pen Schemes hurt ALL Horse.

Say it with me, so you don't get dupod into thinking you're helping while you're actually causing harm.

The now infamous Boyd case was actually built on the back of saving horses from these lots. See how much saving happened there?

Heart of Phoenix has always spoken out against the support of kill pen schemes. Please understand, they are simply a money racket.

And they hurt horses in many ways.

What if I told you the way to solve overbreeding in the pet world from puppy mills was to purchase all the puppies from the unethical breeds each week?

I hope you would see how THAT could NEVER solve the problem; I hope you can see how that would only ever make the situation far worse.

But did you know that is EXACTLY what well-meaning people do daily with Broker lots and Kill Pen Scheme sites?

I understand, if you don’t think about all the components behind the scenes, you may not realize this, so that is why education on the subject is so important.

I saw a graphic once circulating online that made the puppy mill comparison with the Broker lots, and it was absolutely accurate. Buying puppies from mills supports the mills. Buying horses in alleged kill lots supports the abuse, traders and process.

Ending Slaughter Exports will first require we STOP supporting kill pen schemes.

As long as goodhearted horse lovers fund these pretend kill pen sales, those making a fortune with them will continue to work harder and harder to keep the slaughter channels open. The money in actual slaughter isn’t significant anymore, and it is nothing compared to the money made in these scam kill pen businesses.

But what would these businesses do if both borders were closed? They would not be able to lie to you and extort money from people across the county who think they are saving lives from slaughter, anymore.

So while they aren’t sending these numbers of horses to slaughter, being able to lie to you and claim they are means a LOT of money in their pockets weekly, year after year. Fortunes are being made on the backs of nice people who just don’t know better.

And many of the horses suffer, as a result.

The horse market is currently still fairly strong. And the number of horses exported for slaughter was around 25k in 2025, which is down from 133k only ten years ago. The Mexican borders have been closed to exports since midyear.

The decrease in slaughter exports yearly is simply due to less demand outside of the county for US horse meat, and the global trend is declining in general.

The number has never decreased because anyone purchased the horses from kill buyers. Ever.

I feel sure that borders could have been closed some years ago with legislative action had well-meaning, but extremely misguided people, stopped supporting the side industry of “kill pen buying.”

Had we never allowed a massive money making abuse system to grow from the low end auction and/or slaughter of horses, had we called it what it was from day one, the fight to put an end to the export would have been easier, and it actually may have ended before now.

When people purchase these horses being held for ransom, many times, they end up going to people not prepared for the horse they are receiving – donor money paid for the “bail” – the horses arrive somewhere thinner and more injured than they were when they ran through an auction, and over the years, many people have reached out, even other rescues, to turn these horses into us for actual help.

We’ve, most often, actually really ended the cycle for those horses, but they would not have needed it if these sales had no support.

These days, it is impossible to argue that slaughter need remain when so few are shipping and demand internationally for American horses has almost dried up.

But fact is, no matter where you stand on the issue of slaughter of American horses for human consumption, the fact is broker lot schemes hurt ALL horses in many ways.

1.Do not support, share or donate to kill pen scams.

2. Do not support organizations claiming to be rescues that support broker scams

3. Share with others the reasons not to.

4. Reach out to your legislative members and tell them the numbers of horses going over our borders continues to go down yearly, that slaughter isn’t needed to control our horse numbers and request they support an end to export of horses for human consumption.

5. Only give to organizations that steer clear of broke pen scams.

That is how you really help.



Op credit & Tinia Creamer, Heart of Phoenix equine rescue

Excellent information from another reputable rescue. Please don't fall for scams
11/17/2026

Excellent information from another reputable rescue. Please don't fall for scams

Let’s talk about the “border holding facility” lie we keep seeing on horse rescue pages right now. 🐴

For years, certain rescues trained donors to ONLY open their wallets when a horse had a ticking clock over its head: “Donate now or they ship to slaughter tonight.”

Then, in June, the Mexican border shut down to live horse exports. Overnight, those pages lost their main fundraising trigger. Because they had conditioned their followers to only react to life or death panic, they couldn’t raise money anymore without a crisis.
So they invented a new lie: “Holding pens near the Mexican border.”

Now they’re even filming regular horse traders loading trailers at sale barns and claiming those trucks are headed to border holding facilities.

• They aren’t. Those are traders hauling horses from auction to auction.
• Nobody is paying thousands of dollars a day in feed and pen fees to warehouse thousands of horses at a closed border on razor thin meat margins. Those holding pens don’t exist.

The saddest part? They don’t even need to lie.

A horse stuck in the trader circuit, bounced from auction to auction, stressed, and neglected, is already in a terrible situation. Honest rescues pull horses out of those spots all the time and simply tell the truth (and yes, we have bought horses out of loose auctions or from traders ourselves; we just call it what it is: getting a horse out of a bad situation to rehabilitate, train, and rehome them, never claiming they’re headed to a border holding pen).

Why can’t the panic fundraisers just be honest like that?

Because they trapped themselves.

By training the public to only donate to fake emergencies, they killed their own ability to fundraise for real rescue work, leaving legitimate rescues struggling to buy hay while “bailed” horses vanish after one freedom ride photo.

Compassion shouldn’t require a lie. Support transparent rescues that tell you the truth and show you the whole journey, from rehab to adoption. 🐴

Address

4725 U.S. 150
Palmyra, IN
47164

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm
Saturday 11am - 2pm

Telephone

(502) 424-4987

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Misfit Toys Rescue Division, Inc- Equine Sanctuary:

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby pet stores & pet services