
06/23/2025
So true, and so sad. It's supposed to be about what makes the horse feel better, NOT which trim method was used. Some days, I can't even read through the threads I used to learn from because the venom is so unhealthy for my soul.
The Hoof Care Wars: When Helping Horses Became a Battlefield
There was a time when the hoof care world was split simply: shoes or no shoes.
But times have changed.
Today’s conflicts are far more… evolved.
Now we have schools vs schools.
Or more accurately — one or two very specific schools versus…
well, everyone else.
Veterinary surgeons?
“Brainwashed by outdated models.”
Farriers?
“Still stuck in the dark ages.”
Independent trimmers?
“Unqualified. Dangerous. Actively harming horses.”
Yes — welcome to the world where if you’re not trained by their method, using their terminology, applying their trim, and chanting their jargon — you’re a threat to equine welfare.
An obstacle. A danger.
A hoof butcher.
And it’s getting poisonous.
What do these wars actually look like?
Online groups policed like secret societies, where dissent is flagged faster than a loose shoe.
Case studies weaponised to prove “everyone else is incompetent.”
Vets, farriers, physios and other professionals shut down or publicly shamed for not subscribing to “The Method.”
Emotionally charged accusations:
“That trim is abuse.”
“You’re setting that horse up to fail.”
“You’re killing horses.”
Not... “I disagree,”
but:
“You’re endangering lives.”
Meanwhile, in the real world...
Owners are caught in the middle, more confused than ever.
Horses are left without consistent, collaborative care.
Practitioners feel under siege, walking on eggshells rather than sharing knowledge.
Thoughtful discussion dies a slow death, buried under dogma.
And those who try to build bridges?
Mocked, blocked, or labelled "fence-sitters."
The horse does not care which school you trained with.
He cares whether he can land heel-first.
Whether he can move freely.
Whether his posture is improving.
Whether his pain is being addressed.
Horses don’t need ideology.
They need clarity.
Competence.
Care.
So let’s drop the slogans and the sanctimony.
Let’s stop declaring war on anyone who doesn’t echo our training manual.
No single school owns hoof care.
No method is universally right for every horse, in every context.
And if your training can’t stand up to scrutiny, open discussion, or collaboration with other professionals —
then it’s not a method.
It’s a religion.
And horses deserve better than that.