08/12/2025
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: the dog gets to decide what’s rewarding.
That’s not me being soft or letting the dog run the show, it’s just how learning works. If your dog doesn’t think something is worth their time, then it’s not a reward, it’s just… something you keep handing them while they stare off wishing for something better.
And here’s where handlers often get it wrong:
• The “but it’s good food!” mistake.
You’ve bought the expensive treats. They smell like they could knock a buzzard off a gut wagon. But your dog? Your dog is more interested in sniffing the grass where a squirrel was three days ago. It’s not that they’re ungrateful, it’s just that in that moment, squirrel-scent is a stronger currency than even your stinky salmon snacks.
• The “play is always fun” assumption.
You toss the toy, expecting your dog to burst into Olympic-level sprints… and they trot after it like they’re auditioning for a slow-motion commercial. Some dogs find toys exciting, some think they’re just odd chewable projectiles that interrupt their day.
• The “praise fixes everything” trap.
You’re gushing “Good dog! GOOD DOG!!” and your dog’s body language is politely saying, “Ma’am… please. I am in the middle of something.” Praise can be powerful, if your dog actually values it in that moment.
So how do we get it right?
Start by observing. Watch what lights your dog up. The way their eyes brighten. The little bounce in their step. The “heck yes, let’s do more of that” energy. That might be a certain type of treat, a particular tug toy, a sniff break, the chance to chase you, or simply being allowed to figure something out without interruption.
Then here’s the trick, use the right reward for the right situation. High distraction? Bring out the big guns. Low distraction? Keep it simple. Match the currency to the value of the work you’re asking for.
Why does this matter? Because training isn’t just about teaching skills, it’s about building a relationship where your dog thinks, working with you is the best part of my day. And when they feel that way? Suddenly, the skills stick faster, the focus lasts longer, and you stop feeling like you’re bribing your dog and start feeling like you’re in a partnership.
So no matter how much you paid for those artisanal, grain-free, gently hand-massaged yak milk chews, if your dog isn’t into them, they’re not a reward. Let your dog have a say. They’re the ones doing the work, after all.