11/13/2026
👍🏼
“You know what I mean,” we tell the dog, who has just heard us say “down” while pointing at the sofa. We have spent three weeks teaching that word, paid for a class, practised in the kitchen and distributed enough chicken to provision a small expedition, so the dog lies down on the sofa and looks pleased with themselves.
We meant get off. The dog did what we said, which has somehow landed them in trouble.
Dog training makes sense when you are the person who knows what is supposed to happen. We know what we want, why we want it and which exceptions apply, including the ones we have just invented because company is coming. The dog is working from whatever information we have managed to make available, some of which bears only a passing resemblance to what we think we taught.
Take jumping up. Yesterday we came home in barn clothes, slapped our thighs and welcomed a greeting that involved front feet somewhere around our waist. Today we are dressed for dinner, and the same greeting earns a reprimand. We understand the difference between those two situations because we paid for the trousers. The dog sees the same person coming through the same door and uses the greeting that worked yesterday.
Then there is “leave it,” which we haven’t actually trained but expect the dog to understand because we know what we mean. We use it for don’t eat the sandwich, stop sniffing that person, turn away from the other dog or abandon whatever you are doing behind the shed, without having taught the dog what response those words require. Sometimes we haven’t even seen what they are doing behind the shed, but we dislike the lack of supervision and feel an instruction is warranted.
We also teach things we have no idea we are teaching. We say “sit” while facing the dog, leaning forward, raising a hand and putting the other hand in the treat pouch. After several successful repetitions, we tell people the dog knows “sit.” Later, carrying groceries and looking for our keys, we say the word without any of the accompanying movements, then repeat it more loudly when nothing happens.
The dog learned something during those practice sessions. Whether it was the word, the raised hand, our position or the promising sound of fingers rummaging among the treats is a question we have skipped in our enthusiasm to declare the lesson complete.
The dog’s difficulty becomes harder to understand once we decide it is deliberate. “Stubborn” saves us the trouble of examining what we taught, and “testing me” gives the whole business a motive. We can then spend the session trying to win an argument the dog doesn’t know we are having.
None of this requires us to abandon our expectations, but we do have to account for how the dog is supposed to recognise them. Before repeating an instruction with increasing indignation, we can look at what helped the dog succeed before, what has changed and whether we ever taught the part we are now demanding.
Your dog has not read your training plan, and being disappointed in them won’t supply the missing information.
What has your dog learned from you that you had no intention of teaching?