01/23/2025
TODAY OUR BREED EXPERT Carol Price looks at:
‘FEAR OF THE NEW’ BEHAVIOURS IN BORDER COLLIES
Recently a follower asked for advice about their 3 year old Border collie who had developed an instant terror of some new signs that has been placed in the road outside her home. “He really is deathly afraid of them,” she said, “and does not want to go near them or past them, even though he has not had problems with other road signs before.”
Reacting to ‘newer’ sights, sounds or experiences with immediate fear is such a familiar issue in Border collies, for reasons I hope to explain in more depth in this feature. For to better resolve or manage this phenomenon in your dog, you first have to better understand it.
EARLIEST EXPOSURE AND LEARNING
This begins with the reality that dogs cannot be born understanding what we already know about our world. All the different sights and sounds they get exposed to in their daily living environment; why they exist, what they mean, and whether or not they are potentially threatening to them. It is something they have to more gradually learn and process instead, from earliest puppyhood onwards, each and every time they encounter something ‘newer’ or ‘stranger’. And that includes newer people, dogs or other animals, and a variety of different new social experiences too.
Most breeders – or owners who get their puppies at an earlier age - will be aware of that moment when a puppy, who had previously taken everything around them in their stride, suddenly reacts more adversely – i.e. with noticeable alarm or outright fear – to something completely new that is introduced to them. It could be something as simple as a bucket placed on the floor, or a sound they have not heard before or someone wearing something less usual, like a hat. And such behaviour signals the beginning of the classic ‘fear response’ kicking in in young dogs, when anything immediately more different or ‘less usual’ to the dog so far, in their lives, also becomes something to be treated with far greater suspicion.
This inherent response – which is also a basic survival one – is part of natural development in dogs and will typically begin around 6-8 weeks in pups, though in some dogs it could be even earlier or later. It also reinforces the vital need, once again, for puppies to be given a far wider degree of socialisation - and exposure to umpteen different sights, sounds, people, and experiences, both inside and outside the home, including car travel – well before they leave their breeder. As you will never get a better opportunity to familiarise dogs to newer things than during this earliest phase of development. A reason I begin myself taking my own puppies out in the car, and carrying them around different places, and noisier or more busy social environments, from around 4-5 weeks onwards.
DIFFERING RESPONSES
Collies can still vary so much, in terms of the type of response they will have to newer things. Depending on how they are more individually wired, and what past socialisation or training they have had to cope better with ‘newer things’, their reaction may range from simple curiosity to outright terror. Similarly, while some dogs may choose to process their alarm about newer or stranger things into more phobic-type behaviours – like running away or hiding – others may adopt more defensive-aggressive reactions towards them instead (i.e. lunging, barking, growling).
To me what can also be critical in any dog is how quickly they are able to recover from a ‘fear of the new’ fright once it has happened. In other words, file off the ‘newer thing’ in their brains as not really that harmful after all, and then not worry about it anymore.
It might sound simple but this basic ‘quicker recovery’ ability, in any dog, can make such a difference to the future quality of life they lead. I.e. one in which everything newer immediately becomes far more terrifying to them, or something they will more quickly accept, instead, as part of their everyday lives. It also explains why some dogs will always find it much harder than others to get over their fears about different things in later life.
THE ‘FEAR SWITCH’
As owners, we often do not understand the struggles our dogs may have every day, trying to understand or process every newer or stranger thing that they are exposed to in their surrounding environment. Which they then have to file off into the appropriate category in their brains – i.e. safe or less safe. It is a constantly ongoing process that we can pretty much take for granted, instead, until something in particular suddenly flicks our dog’s ‘fear switch’ more dramatically. And brings us back, face to face, with the more primal dog brain.
Owners can get very frustrated with dogs who mount more excessive fear or defensive responses to things that they know themselves to be quite harmless. Or try to over-pressurise them into getting nearer to them before they are ready. Because they are human, with decades of past social exposure and experience behind them, of a kind dogs cannot have. Only an ability to process, from scratch, every individual new experience that comes their way, and decide how they should react to it.
STORING ‘PICTURES’
It can also be helpful to understand how dogs mentally store their acquired experiences of life; i.e. much like ‘pictures’ (see my accompanying illustration), to which they will then attach more positive or negative associations. So they will see or sense a ‘picture’ of something appearing or happening in their immediate environment, and refer the picture back to their memories. Their memories will then tell them whether this picture features something already familiar, or not, and what associations – good, bad or just neutral - they made with it in the past. This in turn will then trigger the dog’s response whenever they see the same picture again.
Alternatively, if they have not seen the picture before they will need to decide whether they are going to store it as ‘safe’ or not. And sometimes this process can happen very, very, quickly. However, once you understand the whole concept of ‘pictures’ and mental associations in dogs, you will also see how the key to getting dogs to change their more fearful reactions to a negative ‘picture’ is to make that picture become more positive in their minds instead.
You can do this by more gradual exposure to the initially more frightening thing, at a level they progressively cope better with, and constantly rewarding any signs of growing confidence in them with praise and rewards. And also by teaching your dog to understand that when you give them a specific command or instruction – I like to use ‘go see!’ – whatever they are about to approach will be safe.
THE BEST APPROACH
The best opportunity you will ever have to change a dog’s perception of something new from potentially negative to positive is also the very first time they are exposed to it. Alternatively once a negative association is allowed to become more established in a dog’s mind towards something – usually through them constantly repeating a more negative response to it – it can take a lot longer to change. Constantly avoiding what makes your dog fearful will have the same effect.
You will need patience, and persistence, only every progressing at a pace the dog is able to cope with, in building greater confidence, but it is the only way to eventually change the way a dog responds to something they previously feared.
Meanwhile far more on socialisation and social training for Border collies – including the ‘go see!’ training mentioned in this feature - appears in BOOK TWO in my BREED APART trilogy, ESSENTIAL LIFE SKILLS & LEARNING, and all aspects of fear in collies and how to deal with it is covered in BOOK THREE on BEHAVIOUR.
All text ©Carol Price/Collieology 2025
Carol Price collie books: In the UK from: https://performancedog.co.uk/?s=carol+price In the USA from: https://www.dogwise.com/ # and https://www.cleanrun.com/product/border_collies_a_breed_apart_book_1_secrets_of_the_working_mind/index.cfm In Canada from https://4mymerles.com/collections/books In Australia from: https://gameondogs.com.au/ And in the Netherlands and Belgium from: https://mediaboek.nl/border-collies-a-breed-apart-book-1.html