01/26/2024
I’ve heard the argument time and time again that the use of harnesses for anything other than medical reasons and dog sports/draft purposes should be avoided. I recently saw a post in agreement with this argument and while I’m not going to share it because I don’t want to perpetuate false information, I will address the reasons against the use of harnesses that were made by a sharer of this post.
1. Teaches the dog to pull.
- Harnesses do NOT teach dogs to pull. Pulling is a normal side effect of dogs’ naturally faster pace paired with being attached to a 6ft leash (and a slow human). Being successful at pulling reinforces the behavior of pulling.
2. No control.
- The leash and collar/harness are NOT a steering wheel, they are more like a seat belt. There for safety. If you’re struggling to keep your dog with you and walking loosely on leash, further training is needed. That includes training around distractions!
3. Long-necked breeds, like Danes, can sn**ch up something way before the owner can react.
- This seems like an odd point as it would be true regardless of whether you use a collar or a harness. This has more to do with the handler’s reaction time and attention to the dog than with the equipment being used. This is also a training issue, not a harness issue. If your dog struggles around certain things (e.g. strangers, other dogs, etc), this needs to be addressed with proper behavior adjustment training.
4. Can cause injury to front assembly.
- I can agree with this when it comes to harnesses that inhibit movement. This includes some harnesses that are advertised as “no pull” harnesses. These harnesses tend to cut across the shoulder, thus affecting how the dog moves its front legs. This can cause changes to the dog’s normal gait and lead to injury. A properly fit harness that allows for normal front limb range of motion should not cause injury.
Regardless of whether you choose to use a harness or collar to train your dog in loose leash walking, it is YOU who trains your dog, not the collar or harness.
Video: my dog, Buzz, doing some lovely loose leash walking in a harness.