08/22/2025
This one always rankles folks.
“Cops and trainers/owners aren’t anything alike!” “It’s not about the threat of unwanted consequences, it’s about the skill, timing, and energy!”
Haha…
So many can’t stand the thought of needing to be an authority figure with their dogs, and everyone is certain that only a monster would imply that the *threat* of unwanted consequences even play a role in their dog’s behavior.
We much prefer the romantic, sweet, love will solve it all, dogs just want to please, teach them what you want and they’ll happily do it… beliefs.
And yet we all know that we ourselves behave differently when the threat of unwanted consequences are in play… and we laughingly share stories of dogs who are angels with one owner and devils with another… or how they their naughtiness disappears the second their trainer appears.
Same you, different behavior depending on who’s present — same dog, different behavior depending on who’s present.
So what about the “skill, timing, and energy” claims? They’re all true — but what are they being used for? Some would say, “To properly reward/cultivate desired behavior, communicate clearly and effectively, and build a healthy relationship.” Yep. Absolutely true.
But the other side of this “skill, timing, and energy” coin is that these are being used to properly punish/discourage undesired behavior, communicate clearly and effectively where the boundaries are and what the consequences are for trespassing against these established boundaries… and build a healthy relationship.
The only difference between the trainer (or you) and the cop is that the cop is ONLY there to enforce rules/laws. The trainer’s and your job is far more nuanced, and thus for many owners far more emotionally difficult — but also far more fun. Your job is to love, play, feed, adventure, romp — aka, share all the soft and fun stuff — but critically, to also share the unpleasant consequences that balance everything out and cause your dog to offer their best, and to inhibit their worst.
You and your dog aren’t any different. Even if you don’t like to hear to me say it.