Rubin Livestock Services: Horse Division

Rubin Livestock Services: Horse Division Buying & selling all types of quality horses & ponies in Monticello, NY.
845-798-2509 Rubin Livestock Services buys and sells all types of horses and ponies.

We offer everything including trail and backyard horses, western pleasure horses, leadline ponies, school horses, hunters, and more! We also pride ourselves on always having a selection of well-started green hunter horse and pony prospects. We have a horse for every rider across a wide price range. Get in touch with us and we will help you to find your perfect horse or pony! We also have a tack sh

op on premises stocked with new and used tack with several saddles, bridles, stable supplies and other items always available.

Goldie- 16yr, 37” Palomino Pony Mare $2600Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbEVMOB65FA&t=48sGoldie is one of my fa...
06/06/2026

Goldie- 16yr, 37” Palomino Pony Mare $2600

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbEVMOB65FA&t=48s

Goldie is one of my favorite minis we have right now! If you want a pony just to chill with and love on, she is your girl. Walk right up to her in the paddock and brush her and she will be your best friend! Goldie is also an excellent leadline pony. She has been great for our lesson kids to handle. She is good to work around, UTD with the farrier, gets along well with other ponies or bigger horses. And we can't forget to mention her gorgeous color, she is shedding out to be a lovely golden palomino and is really a pretty pony!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Short Stack- 12yr, 33” Paint Mini Mare $3500Video: https://youtu.be/wrg_o7TPlhY?si=jAbxEnz7VoQuKRBULittle, cute, and kid...
06/06/2026

Short Stack- 12yr, 33” Paint Mini Mare $3500

Video: https://youtu.be/wrg_o7TPlhY?si=jAbxEnz7VoQuKRBU

Little, cute, and kid friendly! Short Stack is super well broke to ride. She will do the leadline job or walk, jog, and lope independently for the right kid! You don't find many ponies that ride this well in her size. Short Stack has been ridden in the arena and outside. She has also been handled by the kids and is a nice tolerant little girl. I was told when I bought Short Stack that she is broke to drive, but we have not personally hooked her. She's friendly with a nice pony personality and gets along well in a mixed herd of minis currently. Sometimes takes a snack to catch her like a typical pony, but she is otherwise perfectly easy to handle and have in the barn. A really cool little girl that would be great for little kids pony rides, lessons, or just to enjoy riding around the farm!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Chocolate Chip- 18yr, 35” Bay Mini Gelding $2600Video: https://youtu.be/qmEfXxzESIw?si=mNvmWYhSd607jqxAIf you’re looking...
06/06/2026

Chocolate Chip- 18yr, 35” Bay Mini Gelding $2600

Video: https://youtu.be/qmEfXxzESIw?si=mNvmWYhSd607jqxA

If you’re looking for a kid friendly pony, meet Chocolate Chip! This little guy is a saint. He will do the leadline, ride independently for a kid that can make him go (he’s on the lazy side), and has been ponied on the trail as well. He’s a good little guy that is the same if you play with him every day or once a week. I am told he is also broke to drive, but I have not personally hooked him. Chocolate Chip is the kind of good old pony that the kids can learn with safely. He is currently barefoot and sound with no hoof issues. Easy to groom and tack, stands tied nicely, gets along with other pones, a pleasure to have around the farm. Takes a snack to catch him sometimes, but otherwise he is 100% gentle and easy! We love this little guy!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Fred- 18yr, 36” Sorrel Mini Gelding $1550Video: https://youtu.be/Swv4B8j5fTI?feature=sharedFred is that pony who needs s...
06/06/2026

Fred- 18yr, 36” Sorrel Mini Gelding $1550

Video: https://youtu.be/Swv4B8j5fTI?feature=shared

Fred is that pony who needs someone who's going to love him- no matter what- just because he's cute. He is an excellent companion that gets along with ponies or bigger horses. He is good to groom and work around, but probably would excel more with someone who just wants to give him love vs. a crowd of kids. Has been great for our lesson kids that are experienced with ponies to handle, but will move away from a lot of fast activity if he's not sure. He can be a little hard to catch out in the paddock, definitely takes a snack to get his attention, but he has been improving with regular attention here. I was told that Fred was broke to ride and sat for a few years, but he did not appreciate our attempts to put a rider on, so I think he would be happier to continue in the companion role. He is sound, UTD with farrier, has good feet with no issues, current coggins and deworming. Ready to go be a nice companion and just wants someone to love him for who he is!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Meg- 16yr, 34" Liver Chestnut Mini Mare $1950 Video: https://youtu.be/OWfeaNtu5co?feature=shared A pretty little girl th...
06/06/2026

Meg- 16yr, 34" Liver Chestnut Mini Mare $1950

Video: https://youtu.be/OWfeaNtu5co?feature=shared

A pretty little girl that is an excellent companion! Meg gets along with everyone and just wants to be a pet. Takes a snack to catch her sometimes, but she is absolutely perfect otherwise! Great to work around, loves attention and grooming, a very sweet pony that is easy to handle. Meg is UTD with coggins, deworming, and the farrier. She is a chubby girl and the farrier did recommend she live on a dry lot or wear a grazing muzzle. She is a super easy keeper and a really nice pony to have in the barn.

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Sandy- 2yr, 33” Palomino Gelding Mini $3800Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b7pvnwb5iUIf you don't have time to s...
06/06/2026

Sandy- 2yr, 33” Palomino Gelding Mini $3800

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2b7pvnwb5iU

If you don't have time to stop and love on a pony everytime you walk by, then Sandy is not the guy for you. This absolute superstar of a young pony is a total lovebug that wants to be in your business all the time and is as in your pocket friendly as a mini can get. Besides his lovely personality, this little dude is also already well broke to ride and drive. I bought him from the Amish kids that started him, and they did a fabulous job! He will ride ba****ck or saddled, in a halter or with a bridle. Has been ridden outside and in the arena. He was also driven a bunch before he came here and is a pony that can do any job. He has good feet, is UTD with the farrier, coggins, and deworming. Turns out with a mixed group of minis and gets along fine. You don't have to worry about catching him, he will catch you. He is still a baby so still learning, but he has a phenomenal start on him and is going to grow up to be a wonderful pony with a bright future ahead of him. We love him!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Comet- 18yr, 37” Leopard Appaloosa Gelding $2750Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmLDqZk8DzUThe cutest loud colore...
06/06/2026

Comet- 18yr, 37” Leopard Appaloosa Gelding $2750

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmLDqZk8DzU

The cutest loud colored appy pony. He is an adorable chunk, and you don't find many this spotted up his size! Comet has been a companion pony for the last few years, gets along with everyone we have put him with and is a friendly guy. Comet hadn't been ridden in several years, but we've got him back to work doing leadline rides for our lesson kids and he tries hard to please. Can be shy at first, but the more time we spend with him the better he gets. As you can tell from his figure, he will never turn down a snack and a treat is the key to his heart! Comet is UTD with farrier and sound with no hoof issues, has a current coggins, and is ready to go be a fabulous companion or continue getting back into the leadline groove!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Lady Bug- 8-10yr, 14.2h Spotted Saddle Horse Mare $2200Video: https://youtu.be/S0bHhKVvN3U?si=Zh86xadTfBvpAsw7A cool gai...
06/04/2026

Lady Bug- 8-10yr, 14.2h Spotted Saddle Horse Mare $2200

Video: https://youtu.be/S0bHhKVvN3U?si=Zh86xadTfBvpAsw7

A cool gaited horse that loves to hit the trails! Lady Bug was well started as a youngster and then went to folks who had intentions to ride, but mostly kept her as a pet! We've got her restarted and she improves with every ride. Loves to hit the trails with friends, and seems brave enough to go on her own too! She has also started on some arena work and likes to have a job. Lady Bug needs a little consistency to work on her manners (not mean, just pushy if you let her be and needs work on standing when mounting). She would be a fun horse for someone who likes a gaited horse with a little pep, great for a teenager that wants a project to bring along this summer! Barefoot, sound, turns out in a group and is everyone's friend, easy keeper. Just needs a job!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Julie- 12yr, 15.2-15.3h Draft Cross Mare $3500Video: https://youtu.be/wCbvbTTFkuk?si=rKbes3hqrX8dfDyXJulie came off an A...
06/04/2026

Julie- 12yr, 15.2-15.3h Draft Cross Mare $3500

Video: https://youtu.be/wCbvbTTFkuk?si=rKbes3hqrX8dfDyX

Julie came off an Amish farm where she was used to ride and drive. She is a fabulous trail horse, goes where you point her, and will ride with friends or out on her own. Crosses water, good with cars, a very sensible horse. Would be perfect for a husband or guest horse as she is straight forward to ride. While I have not personally hooked her, she was being used for regular trips up until when I bought her, and I have no doubt that she would hook up and drive just fine. She had 4 shoes when she was driving, she is currently barefoot and seems to be fine that way. Julie turns out with a group and gets along fine. She is easy to catch, content outside or in a stall, good to groom and tack. She makes mare faces, but never actually ever makes a wrong move! She's a sweetheart that we think anyone can get along with!

Located in Monticello, NY
Tack shop on premises!
www.rubinlivestockservices.com

Address

93 Rubin Road
Monticello, NY
12701

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 8pm
Saturday 8am - 8pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Telephone

+18457982509

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rubin Livestock Services: Horse Division posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Rubin Livestock Services: Horse Division:

Shortcuts

Share