07/18/2025
Have you ever adopted a dog/puppy who had the best manners at first and then later on behavior issues seemed to arise?
This is something we call the honeymoon period, and it gets a lot of play. Over and over, we hear owners sharing how a newly adopted dog/puppy came in, was easy, quiet, polite, friendly, and even cautious.
And how nice is that? The perfect dog. 🙂
Of course, that all makes perfect sense. It’s a new environment, with new sights, sounds, people, and maybe even animals. That means there’s an awful lot to take in, process, and figure out.
This means that as your new pup is immersed in all this “newness”, being cautious and careful behaviorally is exactly what you’d expect.
But then...
But then you start to see some shifts. A bit more barking at the doors or windows, a bit more nervous reacting to strangers, a bit more pulling on leash, a bit more revving up at other dogs on the walks, a bit more rambunctiousness around you and the kids...or maybe the cat or other dog.
And then, it gets worse. Perhaps it’s the issues above intensifying, or perhaps it’s something even more worrisome... maybe some previously unseen resource guarding of space or people or food? Or maybe some out and out attacks on the other dog or the cat? Or...?
Here’s the thing, none of this is mysterious. Your pup has been smart; she has been getting the lay of the new land and finding her bearings. But there’s another component, which is a major player in this unfolding drama.
You.
Most dogs who come into new homes don’t get introduced to structure, rules, leadership, and accountability. No. Instead, they come into homes and are enveloped with affection, play, toys, and total freedom (“Explore your new house!”), and a deep, deep desire for them to be “happy".
Over time, as your pup gets comfy with the environment, and more dangerously, crystal clear on the social structure of the home - meaning, humans are soft, sweet, boundary-less, eager-to-please doormats - things start to change dramatically.
Instead of giving your dog clear instructions on the expectations you have for their behavior, you’ve given them clear instructions that there ARE NO INSTRUCTIONS. And a dog with no instructions, and with no behavioral expectations... also known as a dog without any leadership...is a dog who’s going to find out exactly what he or she can get away with. And once that’s clear, they’re going to work to get away with it, over and over.
Thus, mysteriously and tragically, the honeymoon comes to an end. At this point, some people seek help, and many others simply return the dog. Not realizing that the dog didn’t reveal it’s true self, but that the dog was allowed to reveal its worst self. And that the revealing was allowed, and actually created by you. All because you wanted the new pup to be “happy”, rather than stable. “Loved” rather than led.
Another example of good intentions, all-be them ill-informed, creating a tragic outcome.
This is where stepping up as the calm, confident, and relaxed leader comes into play. Setting strong rules, boundaries, and limitations in the household while knowing when to correct at the precise moment is what is necessary to reveal your pup's best self. We talk continuously about exercise, discipline, and affection in that order daily. Without that order, chaos is created, and the pup's worst self will emerge.