04/21/2026
This is the same horse from the last two posts.
8 months into rehab… and, crucially, the toe is still there.
Everyone says: 👉 “remove the toe”
And we understand why.
Because you’ve been taught that:
> the toe is a lever
> it pulls on the laminae
> it must be taken back to reduce strain on the soft tissues
So logically…
removing it should make the horse more comfortable?
But here’s the problem with that idea:
👉 We didn’t remove it.
Not at the start.
Not during rehab.
Not now.
And this horse didn’t:
get worse
stay in pain
need ongoing support from shoes or boots
👉 He improved.
So what actually changed?
While people obsess over the toe…
they miss:
👉 The balance. The depth.
This foot was realigned onto his balanced plane in trim one (previous post).
The load was redistributed.
The strain was reduced through alignment, not by removing structure at the toe.
Because when you remove the toe too early:
• you remove the toe support
• you force load under P3
• you reduce comfort
• you risk losing the very sole depth the horse needs to protect himself
👉 which is exactly what had already happened before he arrived for rehab.
Remember…
He was going to be PTS.
Vets and farriers said they had “tried everything”.
But they hadn’t tried this.
So instead of continuing down the same path -
shoes, restriction, and the belief that P3 moves independently of the capsule - we allowed:
• depth to return under P3
• support to rebuild
• the foot to stabilise
👉 even before the laminae had fully repaired.
And now?
👉 He’s moving comfortably
👉 Barefoot
👉 On challenging surfaces
👉 Without the drugs or shoes he was told he needed
So think on this…
If the toe was the problem…
👉 the laminae shouldn’t be repairing.
👉 and he certainly shouldn’t be sound.
So the real question is:
Why are you trying to force a damaged foot to look “normal”…
at the expense of comfort?
You see a long, horizontal “ugly toe”.
We see:
👉 vertical depth returning
👉 comfort increasing
👉 a horse recovering
And alive.
HM.
If you want to know about how to save your horse from P3 'rotation', join our free hoof rehab group >> The Phoenix Way: Path 2 Hoof Health