06/05/2026
Negative posts are going around about dog sports and how dogs should be "natural", should not be taught obedience, and should just exist in people's homes to do as they please without much human input or guidance.
This is inaccurate "science".
Most dogs living in the US were bred to work alongside humans originally. They are NOT wolves or any other form of wild canid. They are not a wild species or free-roaming domesticated dogs. They are mostly bred from breeds that were bred for very specific behavior patterns, many were bred for their biddable nature since they were trained to work with a specific human, and ultimately for doing work alongside humans. Dogs have a special social cognition with humans that is shared by no other species. They gravitate toward humans, understand humans' body language and gestures, are quick to pick up on verbal cues even when we are not trying to teach it to them, and they are far more inclined to trust humans than any wild species. This from our unique shared history and thousands of years of domestication.
What is "natural" is not necessarily an improvement on captive animal welfare. In the natural world, anything that enhances survival and reproductive advantages is considered positive and beneficial. Animals that have early adversity in life display HPA axis dysfunctions and display maladaptive behaviors like hypervigilance, but they also live longer. That is considered an advantage in the natural world for a wild animal. Guess what? That is poor welfare for a captive animal. With a captive animal, the goal is not "survival". The goal is enjoying a life worth living.
Most dogs that I encounter are highly under-stimulated, under-socialized, and under-prepared for the social situations they are expected to navigate inside the home and away from home. Some people don't even have their dogs leave the home even for a walk most days or even most weeks, which is really sad. Dogs are curious and typically are social creatures, but not when they are so deprived of early socialization that the world is fearful to them. Obedience should not be about control but more of teaching a way to communicate to your dog how to handle a particular situation -- such as cueing your dog to turn and move away from a social situation if they look slightly stressed by a person or other dog's behavior; standing or sitting for a greeting (not jumping); teaching a dog to ignore other dogs and people while on leash; teaching coping skills around things that frustrate the dog -- like seeing something they want but cannot have at this moment; teaching respectful boundaries around access to resources when they are multiple dogs in the home -- resource guarding is a sign of anxiety and insecurity; teaching the dog not to pick up everything off the ground or off the dinner table that could potentially hurt them. We do this with human children so they can learn boundaries and feel safe to operate within them in the world. This should all be taught in a way with rewards that is fun and enhances welfare, not compromises it.
But we should never forget that dog should be exhibiting normal "dog" behaviors to be healthy. What those look like can vary by dog because breeds are bred for such highly specific patterns, but there are cross-overs between breeds. The preferences of the individual take primacy over "breed" or anything else. Practicing these behavior patterns are essential to their well-being! But scheduling out enrichment is not sufficient. That sounds like life in a prison where you get meals brought to you, time in the gym, your visitor hour, and everything is decided for you. A key component of welfare is having CHOICE. This includes having the freedom to CHOOSE what to do at given times. Having choices over chewing items, when and where to rest, toys they enjoy to play with, choices over food that they find palatable and enjoyable and having some variety if possible, choosing when to go on walks, where they might like to walk, letting their owner know that they would like to do training, regular meet ups with friends (since they can't grab the keys and leave), freedom to occasionally meet another dog or person they might like to say "hello" to on the street if the other party agrees, asking the owner for attention of play time, etc. There has to be two-way communication. My dog can let me know when and where he wants to walk by going to two different doors. One goes to the garage where we will drive to a park. The other door is the front door to the neighborhood. He also can let me know when he wants to train agility by going to the back door and nosing his toys. He also knows how to ask for specific stomach medications if he is having an IBD flare. These things matter.
My dog is my partner. He has saved my life, as a diabetic and him as my diabetic alert/response dog. He is a Nederlandse Kooikerhondje, which means "the hunter's dog". He was bred to work closely alongside one person. And that is what he does.
That said, there are a lot of concerns I have with the way *some* people in the dog sports world use harsh training (especially in the bite sports and obedience), deprive their dogs of autonomy, deprive them of the ability to engage in normal behaviors with excessive crating, and other forms of welfare deprivation to build arousal and engagement with the handler. At least in the agility world, this type of approach has fallen wayyyy out in favor in the last several years (thank goodness!). The problem is not with sports. Sports enhance welfare and the dog-human bond. The problem is with the way a minority of people approach training and engaging in the sport. When we trial, I do not even bring a crate if my husband is there. If he is not there, my dog is crated for ten minutes while I walk the agility course to learn the sequence. Otherwise, we are having fun finding his dog friends at the event and socializing, watching other other teams run, sniffing wherever he would like to go, and lying in the grass together. Most people know that I have been very active in trying to change the culture of dog sports both in my local area, but also with mounting campaigns to enhance safety-related policies with the American Kennel Club. Changes occur in culture, practices, and policies when we actively advocate for them.
Working with a human is very natural for a dog. It is exactly what most were bred to do. However, the working relationship with the dog shouldn't be abused and it sometimes is. These posts going around focusing on making dogs an object in the home without guidance on how to feel safe in and navigate the world, without respect for what dogs were bred to do and their special relationship with humans, without stimulation... it is very sad to me because there is some missing out on what dogs' needs actually are and the connection between dogs and humans. People's hearts are in the right place, but the answer to problems in the obedience training world and dog sports is not abandonment of these things that can help meet dogs' needs.
---------------------
Update: Internet trolls will have their posts deleted. I respond to people who want to engage in genuine dialogue, but trolling and/or making nasty comments about me or my dog's photo and other inappropriate things is simply unprofessional and I lack the time for it since I am busy with clients full time and 25-30 hours per week with graduate school. The big question: why do people troll? They likely are unhappy in their own lives, feel helpless in a world that is moving on without them and not representing how they feel things should be, and they feel powerless about. It is sad that anyone could find something wrong with a post promoting the dog-human relationship, advocating for more choices for and understanding of our animals. It is sadly likely reflective of the mindsets and emotional states of the individuals making these arguments. This page is not an open forum. It is my personal business page promoting best industry practices, training and behavior information from research publications, and my own knowledge and opinions from personal experience.
-- Eileen Koval, CDBC, CBCC-KA, CPDT-KA, MSc
M.S. Candidate Applied Animal Behavior and Welfare (graduating 2026, Husson University)
Photograph courtesy of Tiffany F. Photography