06/12/2025
This can apply to the Presa breed in many ways
AKC recognition could be disastrous to the breed in that it gives way for the already prevalent issue of unscrupulous breeding practices.
While I show and compete in akc events, I do not do it with the intention of achieving full recognition, I do it because I love showcasing the versatility of my dogs and my beloved breed. Any breeder worth their salt should be competing in events with the goal of creating ethical breeding practices, consistency and accountability.
AKC Recognition should not be the goal, but a natural outcome along the way for the growth & preservation of a rare breed.
The Drentsche Patrijshond is an FSS breed; meaning, our pedigrees are recorded by AKC and the breed is allowed to compete in many AKC events/sports, but the breed is not yet "fully" recognized in the AKC system and thus can't participate in certain venues like all-breed shows, field trials, etc.
It's not uncommon for folks involved in FSS breeds to make AKC recognition their holy grail, and that seems strange to me. Besides some additional showing opportunities and increased visibility of the breed in the US, full AKC recognition doesn't really offer much. And when you have a small-population rare breed that has only a handful of dogs showing and only a handful of breeders producing puppies, what's the point of those two benefits, anyway?
There is a very understandable desire among folks who are passionate about their breed to see them recognized on the same plane as more common breeds. There can be a weird attitude from other purebred enthusiasts that breeds that aren't recognized are somehow "less than" those that are, or that more breeds achieving full recognition is somehow detrimental to those who have long been. And that can be understandably frustrating to those of us who have breeds that, while rare, often have long and storied histories, and wonderful qualities that make them worth stewarding into the future.
But by rushing to full recognition before a breed is ready, are we not in some way proving these naysayers right? If a breed achieves full recognition but then is rarely if ever seen at all-breed shows or other events, and when they are, the consistency & quality of dogs isn't there, is the mantle of "full recognition" really meaningful at all?
It's no secret that I'm an advocate for the Drentsche Patrijshond eventually achieving full recognition with AKC. But for me, I want to see a thriving, sustainable community built on passion for the breed, not one laser-focused on the AKC goalpost. When that milestone is passed, I want it to be just that, a milestone, not the end-goal.
I want Drent owners showing their dogs in conformation & sports & tests & events because they love doing it with these talented dogs, not because we need a certain amount of competitors for AKC to recognize the breed. I want breeders who are growing the breed population thoughtfully, sustainably, and collaboratively with the goal of preservation, not to meet a certain number of registrations for AKC's benefit. I want a community of owners - exhibitors, breeders, and those with "just pets" - that is thriving and enjoyable and supportive of all levels of involvement in the breed, not just a clique of those who are involved in "AKC stuff" running the show.
I don't want Drents to be the next Golden Retriever or Lab or Frenchie. I want them to be Drents, preserved for their uniqueness and history, thriving and sustainable into the future. If we achieve AKC recognition along the way? Awesome. But that'll just be a bonus.
I encourage other folks involved in FSS breeds to consider - what's the rush towards recognition? What does full AKC recognition offer your breed, truly? When your breed achieves full recognition, will they have the numbers and the quality to take advantage of the benefits of participating at all-breed shows? Do you have enough responsible breeders to meet a potentially increased demand for puppies? Most importantly, do you have a broad enough base to sustain your breed not just through recognition, but generations into the future?