The Sugared Pony

The Sugared Pony We specialize in custom treats for both horses & dogs!🐴🐶💕

All 6 of these are available for pickup or local delivery this week only - we are going on vacation Saturday 10/25 Each ...
10/21/2025

All 6 of these are available for pickup or local delivery this week only - we are going on vacation Saturday 10/25

Each pack is $10🩷

👻
10/20/2025

👻

Place your orders now! Going to try and get in the kitchen tomorrow!💕
10/16/2025

Place your orders now! Going to try and get in the kitchen tomorrow!💕

Going to be making some muffins this weekend! Place your orders now! We have candy corn, candy corn pumpkins, monsters, ...
10/16/2025

Going to be making some muffins this weekend!
Place your orders now!
We have candy corn, candy corn pumpkins, monsters, ghosts & more!

All of these awesome treats are available at ! Head on over & go shopping! They have the cutest stuff!!!
10/11/2025

All of these awesome treats are available at ! Head on over & go shopping! They have the cutest stuff!!!

Give your ponies the cutest snack! •••••
10/07/2025

Give your ponies the cutest snack!
•
•
•
•
•

Available cookies for pick up: 1 pack - Small Hearts (8 per pack) 1 pack - Mini Hearts (12 per pack)1 pack - Poptarts (1...
10/07/2025

Available cookies for pick up:
1 pack - Small Hearts (8 per pack)
1 pack - Mini Hearts (12 per pack)
1 pack - Poptarts (12 per pack)
1 pack - Goldfish (6 per pack)
1 pack - Candy Corn Muffins (12 per pack)

Message me for pricing & to claim!!
(Goldfish in photo are not finished product)

Taking small orders - message me for custom orders🖤🧡

First batch complete! Only 5 more to go!
09/11/2025

First batch complete! Only 5 more to go!

My Caspian trying our new cookies! 🩶We have many different shapes we can use on top of the cookies💙What are your ponies ...
09/11/2025

My Caspian trying our new cookies! 🩶
We have many different shapes we can use on top of the cookies💙

What are your ponies favorite treats?!

We are excited to announce that we are back in business! Our first launch will be at on October 4th! What are you most ...
08/28/2025

We are excited to announce that we are back in business! Our first launch will be at on October 4th!

What are you most excited to see!?

We are super excited to announce we will be at our first event on October 4th held at We hope to see you there!🩷
08/22/2025

We are super excited to announce we will be at our first event on October 4th held at

We hope to see you there!🩷

Just signed up for a vendor sale, hoping we get approved! If so, we hope to see you soon!! What treats would you like to...
08/20/2025

Just signed up for a vendor sale, hoping we get approved! If so, we hope to see you soon!!

What treats would you like to see again?!

Address

Division Avenue
East Islip, NY
11730

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sugared Pony posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Sugared Pony:

Shortcuts

Share

Category