04/22/2025
WHEN CAN WE STOP USING TREATS?
Personally, I will wait until the dog can do a particular behavior 10 out of 10 times WITHOUT me luring them or having to repeat myself. Then I will start to randomize the treats, while increasing the duration in between them. Meaning that I will give treats every other time they correctly perform the behavior, and then every 3 or 4 times, and then I'll drop back down to every single time again for a couple of reps, then go back to 3 or 4 times and continue to build from there. Again, every once in a while, I'm dropping down to every single time, and then going back to the number I was previously at.
This randomization lets the dog know that a treat is coming, they just don't know WHEN, and so they'll continue to show effort. Eventually, we may be giving treats once every 50 times. However, if we start the process and the dog starts to regress (they're not being as responsive), then drop back down to every other time for a little while longer, because they might not be ready for that part, and continue building up.
An important part of this process is that we're doing this with one behavior at a time. So, if we're weaning them off of treats for "Sit," we're still going to be giving treats every single time for "Down" until we have a reliable "Sit" without treats 10 out of 10 times (meaning that I will continue to randomize them until I'm AT LEAST giving treats only once every 10 times they do the behavior). Then we can start working on "Down."
Another important thing is that, when we move into a new environment, we want to start over with treats every time, even if we've already weaned them off in the house. This is just to remind them of the rules of the game, and we'll be able to go through the process a lot faster.
A final note: For me, I will always give treats for the recall (come when called). This is because this is a life-saving skill, so I want the dog as motivated as possible. And, for other behaviors, even after I've weaned them off, occasionally I'll still give treats every single time, just because I want them to always assume a reward COULD BE coming.