08/12/2026
Straight from the horses mouth! A former NYC carriage horse driver whose family owned Chateau Stables calls for shutting down “the dangerous, relic of a trade” NOW in a City and State New York oped! She writes: “The owners and drivers I still speak to are not blinded by nostalgia. They tell me flatly: It’s not like it used to be. It’s not safe. They are contending with noise, congestion and an unpredictable environment. In all my years driving, I never saw this many accidents happen so often. At some point, you must accept that the conditions have changed so much, the practice itself is no longer safe or sustainable.”
The truth is the carriage trade was never safe for horses! That’s why we are advocating for Intro 943, which would phase out the city’s longstanding and controversial horse carriage industry altogether by June 1, 2028, stopping new licenses from being issued immediately. It currently has 29 sponsors (it only needs 26 votes to pass) and we have heard it could be voted on in September. We have told legislators that we support adding language to the bill that creates a fund to enable the city to facilitate a buyout of the horses from the owners and help with placement fees at the sanctuaries who need them. We said we could contribute $25,000 to start and invited the TWU to engage with legislators and us on this. And we expect other groups to step up too.
Read Anita McGill’s oped here:
In all my years of driving a horse carriage, I never saw this many accidents happen so often.