07/17/2025
Wisdom Wednesday!
Check comments for more videos!
Herding breeds are on of the many breed groups that are regularly accused of being reactive, aggressive, stand off-ish, non social, etc.
Letās breakdown why their instinct can result in these types of behavior and how itās often misunderstood ā¬ļø
Upside: While many herding breeds are social in that they like people, dogs, other animals, they have been bred for hundreds of years to be more focused on working alongside a person. To value connection with one person over fitting in with the āpack.ā This aids them well when they are rounding up sheep a hundred yards away and need be tuned into the sound of their personās whistle to know which direction to send the sheep.
Downside: This does not aid them well when they are put into situations where they need to be āchillā or ārelaxā as they are 100x more tuned into yours and others behavior and often willing to jump when they think they are needed, not when their owner asks.
Upside: herding breeds have been bred to control. Thatās exactly what herding is and farmers of livestock often rely on this work. Iāve been lucky enough to see it myself in person and itās incredible!
Downside: When not given an outlet to herd/control something appropriate, they will often find an outlet for that drive and often one we donāt want. This is where is see a lot of reactivity in herding breeds. Itās wanting to control/herd and frustrated they cannot.
Upside: Stalking! This is when herding breed locks in visually and doesnāt let up. A lot of trainers would call this āloadingā but I call it āplanning.ā This is often why pet parents are drawn to herding breedsā¦herding breeds are more able and willing to use their eyes and this leads to them also giving us eager eye contact and connection.
Downside: for your average suburban border collie, they drive sequence of location, planning, acting is never fulfilled. When as far as they get is the planning, they build up frustration that can be scary if you are unaware of the why.
Upside: Their mouth - When a dog is herding, the ability to add the tiniest bit of pressure to a sheep with super soft contact is helpful! These dogs are using a soft mouth for them but we have to take into account what they were bred to herd. The border collie mouth can be soft to work with sheep. The Cattle dog mouth is often soft for a cow but thatās still a big punch for a human on the other side of it.
Downside: herding breeds often bite more than other breeds as a means of communication not because they are aggressive or have intent to hurt.
Knowing this about herding breeds can make a world of difference in living alongside of them. The more we know, the better we can fulfill our dogs and set them up for success!
Iāll be posting about how we see this playing out in social settings next week.