28/10/2026
SOMETIMES TRUST COMES AT A COST
Some of you may remember that our trusty old 4WD broke down in August. It had been a long time coming, but the timing couldn't have been worse. Within the space of just two weeks, our quad bike, trailer and horse float also needed repairs.
For a small sanctuary already stretched to its limits, it was a devastating blow.
Some incredible humans and organisations stepped in to help us, and thanks to their generosity, we were able to start looking for a replacement vehicle.
We were racing against the clock. We had a piggy urgently needing rescue transport, our hay was running out, and we needed a reliable 4WD capable of towing to keep the sanctuary operating.
After several private sales failed their AA checks, we made a deliberate decision to buy from a registered motor vehicle dealer. We thought this was the responsible choice. We wanted the protection of the Consumer Guarantees Act, a vehicle in good mechanical condition, and the reassurance that we were buying from someone whose business and reputation we could trust.
We weren't looking for fancy. We just needed something safe and reliable.
Before purchasing, we spoke at length with the dealer about our needs. We explained how important the vehicle's mechanical condition, towing capacity and 4WD system were to the sanctuary. He reassured us that the vehicle was in good condition, talked about the checks his mechanics carried out, and emphasised our protection under the Consumer Guarantees Act.
And we believed him.
He seemed genuinely nice. He seemed to care about the sanctuary. After everything we'd been through trying to find a vehicle, we thought we had finally caught a break.
We couldn't have been more wrong about how this would unfold.
WARNING SIGNS
During the test drive, we noticed the green 4WD indicator lights flashing while driving in 2H. We asked the dealer about this, and he told us it was normal.
After leaving the dealership, the lights changed, and an orange warning light began flashing. Concerned, we called him. He again reassured us that it was normal and that there was nothing to worry about.
We specifically asked whether he was sure.
He assured us he was.
We wanted to trust that the person who had sold us the vehicle knew what he was talking about. But something didn't feel right, so we pulled over and researched the warning lights ourselves.
We discovered that the indicators warranted concern and that the 4WD system needed to be assessed.
We had just purchased a vehicle that we urgently needed for the sanctuary, and we were already having to investigate a potential fault that we had specifically asked the dealer about before buying it.
We researched whether it was safe to continue using the vehicle for our immediate needs, intending to have the 4WD system assessed by a mechanic and address the issue with the dealership.
We had no idea that things were about to get so much worse.
THE BREAKDOWN
After getting some sleep at a friend's house in North Auckland, we set off early the following morning.
We needed to take a sick hen to the vet, pick up our empty horse float and collect hay. We had already lost precious time, and the animals couldn't wait indefinitely for us to sort out transport.
About 40 minutes from home, while travelling on the highway towing the empty float, there was a loud bang.
The vehicle began shaking, veered towards the side of the road and stopped. Smoke started pouring out.
We jumped out wearing our high-vis vest, desperately trying to alert approaching traffic so that nobody would hit us.
It was terrifying.
We are incredibly grateful that the road wasn't busier and that nobody was hurt. A kind stranger helped tow us out of danger once the smoke had stopped, and our friend came to help.
The radiator had failed so catastrophically that it had broken into multiple pieces.
The independent mechanic's assessment subsequently identified serious engine problems, including concerns consistent with a blown head gasket or cracked cylinder heads, alongside multiple fuel fault codes, leaking rocker cover gaskets and problems with the 4WD system.
The vehicle was no longer fit to drive.
We had bought it less than 24 hours earlier, believing we were securing reliable transport for the sanctuary.
Instead, we were left with a vehicle requiring substantial repairs, stranded on the side of a highway, with animals depending on us and no certainty about how we would get everything done.
WHAT HAPPENED NEXT WAS ALMOST AS DISTRESSING
When we contacted the dealer, we hoped for a reasonable conversation and a willingness to investigate what had happened.
Instead, we experienced an interaction that left us shocked and distressed.
When we explained our expectations of a safe, mechanically sound vehicle and referred to our rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act, we were met with swearing, dismissive comments about the vehicle being 20 years old, and statements that we didn't know what we were talking about.
When we raised the possibility of taking the matter to court, we were told that proceedings would be dragged out so long that we wouldn't have a vehicle at all.
That conversation left us feeling intimidated and deeply concerned about how we were going to resolve the situation.
We had done what we thought was the responsible thing. We had explained our needs, asked questions, relied on the assurances we received and paid for a vehicle from a registered dealer.
Now we were facing the prospect of losing a substantial amount of money while still having to find a way to keep the sanctuary running.
SO NOW WE'RE FIGHTING
The vehicle remains at the independent mechanic's workshop where it was towed. We have obtained an independent assessment, gathered our evidence and pursued the matter through the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal.
After months of correspondence, legal complexities and attempts to resolve the dispute, we are now awaiting a hearing date.
We are seeking to recover our money and have our concerns properly heard.
This process has been exhausting. It has taken time, energy and resources away from the work we should be doing: caring for rescued animals, maintaining their home, arranging urgent transport and making sure everyone is fed and safe.
Every hour spent dealing with this dispute is an hour we could have spent working to raise funds or doing something for the animals.
Every dollar tied up in this situation is a dollar that could have gone towards feed, veterinary care, fencing, infrastructure or emergency rescues.
And fighting to be heard, while already carrying the responsibilities of running a sanctuary, is just a lot.
We know that many people are doing it tough. We know that running a business isn't easy, and we don't expect perfection from every second-hand vehicle.
But we do believe that consumers deserve honesty, safety that serious concerns deserve to be taken seriously, and that people should be able to rely on the assurances they receive when making significant purchases. People, at least, should be safe and I don't like people who take advantage of others.
A vehicle's age does not make it unreasonable to expect a dealer to be honest about its condition or to meet their obligations under the law.
We are not asking for a luxury vehicle. We were trying to secure reliable transport to care for vulnerable animals.
WHY WE'RE SHARING THIS
We won't be naming the dealership while these proceedings are ongoing, because we want to protect the integrity of the process.
But we do want our supporters to understand what has happened, why we've been dealing with this behind the scenes, and why we are having to fight so hard to recover the money we paid.