
28/07/2025
Confusion. And how well horses do in spite of us.
While we may call horses naughty, or ignorant, or belligerent or even arrogant (that was a new one on me) what they very often are, is confused.
Thankfully, most of the people I teach don't call horses these things, but they may still be head scratching as to why a horse is doing a certain thing. Or not doing a certain thing. And usually the reason is again, because a horse is confused. And on top of that, because horses are such amazing learners, their confusion may have lead to them learning completely the arse about face lesson of the one we intended.
While horses are really consistent in their interactions; humans are not. While horses are zen masters of reading intention and movement in each other, we are very often a muddly little skin bag of human emotions and contradictions.
Because we want our horse to be happy, one day we may let them graze as they choose as we wander along. The next day we have somewhere to go in a hurry and haven't got time for this, so we want our horse to walk promptly. But, yesterday we let our horse graze, so they go to do the same again, and can't understand why what worked yesterday isn't working today? They yank harder and we call them annoying. You should hear what they call us.
Here is a story of a confusion I installed in my own good horse, Desmondo. Each time I asked Des to extend his neck I also allowed him to (or asked him to, I wasn't clear) extend his stride. Therefore, every time Des extended his neck, the speed went up. This was a great way to teach my horse to combine two things I didn't mean to combine and being the excellent student that he is, he learned it well.
I very often ask students (and myself) to have a good long think about how we want things to be between us and our horse, and then consider how on earth our horse is to know that? How does the picture in our mind translate to the actual practical conversation we are having we our horse? Every single time you are interacting with your horse, you are filling in some of those puzzle pieces for them. If on some days you're choosing pieces from the box with Buckingham Palace on the cover, and on other day's it's The Wombles, no wonder they can't get a grasp on the full picture.
Along with the many songs I sing to the horses, I also often tell them I am very sorry for my human failings and I will try to do better. The fact they can work out anything in amongst the crazy level of human confusion, speaks more to their good nature than our amazing teaching skills. Thank goodness they are who they are.