19/02/2026
Trainer rant of the day: breeding and mares:
I'm so over hearing people say: she went lame as a yearling and we don’t know why, so we never got her broke or she has a bad attitude and bucks but she's pretty so we are going to breed her. Or we got her shown but had to inject her every 8 weeks to keep her sound, keep her on daily regumate, so we could get through warm up and cocktail her with Ace before each class to get a score, but we are breeding her. Or she only has one club foot, is cow hocked to the point of needing corrective shoes and has a back that’s long enough for the Harlem Globetrotters to sit on, but she’s roan with chrome, so we are breeding her. Why, why, why reproduce it?
Now maybe the injury was a freak accident, after all horses could get hurt in a padded stall or maybe the mares not conformationally correct due to a growth injury, that aside, if she has a bad attitude, why?????
I've ridden over a thousand horses and I've seen more full siblings out of the same mare have bad attitudes than any stallion line I can think of. But it's "pretty" or "flashy" they say. Maybe a baby will help her disposition. Yeah and maybe the foal will be her devil clone.
Well I suppose you can hope, cross your fingers, light some sage, send up a prayer flag, but it's surely setting that foal up for a challenge.
I've personally owned one of the most flashy mares around, she had the best work ethic and try of any horse I've ever ridden, she has no quit. And she had a show record with earnings. BUT I wouldn't have bred her if you paid me. She had a crappy disposition with anyone but me, and I don't mean cute crappy as in she loves me most, I mean crappy! She also had underlying health issues including the fact that she was so athletic but too slow footed in front, so much so that she injured herself unless booted her up more then Madonna. I mean from hoof to knee then taped with vet wrap. Was she fun to ride, I thought so, she'd walk through fire for me, yet she was still naturally so cold backed, that I had to get on behind the barn at horse shows in case she blew up, she was a hassle for my staff and family, no one wanted to catch her much less ride her, she hated to be groomed or messed with, and was a witch in her stall, and destroyed every feeder known to man. I ignored her antics and she rode amazing for me but she was awful unless you were on a cow working her. I think she'd have been an horrible mother and anything with her disposition would be like trying to market a She-Devil, lol. Did I like her, yes, well built, yes, flashy with color, that she had, earnings in the show pen, yes, well bred, Absolutely. But does deserve to be reproduce, plain and simple, hell no. I don't care how cool I thought she was.
Unless you are breeding to keep beyond a doubt (and let's face it life changes, stuff happens, it's really a good idea to always keep in mind what someone else would think of your foal), be smart. Do you really want to reproduce what you’re leading, feeding and riding? Sure you can work on improving traits, but if nothing improved would you be happy? Would it be marketable? Enjoyable?
Then be objective, be critical, pick the best cross for your mare and if you can't afford the best cross, save up or just don't breed her. Be rigid with your judgement, do what's right, for your mare and any future foals, because maybe the best future for her, is not to have a foal at all.
Jen Bulger
Rocky Mountain Performance Horses