
21/08/2025
The Mutty Professor,
I was genuinely saddened to read your recent statement about not allowing your own dogs to socialise with any dog that has previously been trained using an E-collar.
As someone who works closely with dogs and has seen firsthand the results of responsible, ethical E-collar training, I would love the opportunity to challenge the assumptions behind that blanket statement. I could show you hundreds of dogs that have been E-collar trained—many of whom no longer even wear the collar—who display calm, reliable, and respectful behaviour. I truly believe you wouldn’t be able to pick them out in a group, nor would they stand out for any negative reason.
In fact, if you were to observe a mixed group of dogs—some trained with E-collars and some using other methods—I’d wager that the best-behaved dogs, the ones calmly minding their business, responding promptly to cues, and not approaching other dogs uninvited, would be the ones trained with a balanced approach that included E-collars.
That said, I do understand where concerns can come from, especially if someone has seen the tool misused. I’m not here to deny that misuse happens. But to dismiss every E-collar trained dog—and, by extension, every responsible, educated trainer who uses them thoughtfully—feels unfair and counterproductive to the goal we all share: raising safe, happy, well-adjusted dogs.
I’d be more than happy to discuss this further or even organise a demonstration with no pressure or agenda—just open mind and respectful dialogue.