25/01/2021
Well said WPCS
An open letter to the Producers of BBC's Winter Watch
Dear Producers of Winter Watch
I write this letter in response to your recent broadcast where you misled the viewing public with your rash statements regarding the alleged hardiness of the Konik ponies in comparison to indigenous native breeds. Your item thereby undermined and ignored the virtues and inherent suitability of the British Native breeds and in particular the Welsh Mountain Pony to the trials, demands and needs of the RSPB’s projects.
Your presenters inaccurate, conformational comments extolling the virtues and characteristics of the Konik ponies in comparison to other Native breeds referred to small ears, broad chests, and fluffy ears – all of which are not unique to this breed.
As a Public service broadcaster, the BBC has undermined its Reithian principles by failing to educate and inform correctly.
This is a poorly researched item; skimming the topic and of detriment and dis-service to the other native breeds of the UK.
I would like to draw the Production team and The RSPB’s attention to the following indigenous breed.
Welsh Mountain Section A Ponies
The Welsh Pony and Cob Society, and Hill Improvement Societies represent ponies that potentially provide a highly unique genetic resource. These include hardy adaptations to specific environmental features which domestic horses or imported ponies may not express.
Centuries of harsh conditions have ensured the sound constitution of the Welsh mountain ponies. The importance of retaining these genetic lines is imperative to the breed. Proven conservation grazers, they are vital to the landscape of upland Wales and other nutrient poor lowland areas including designated conservation areas. This native breed is also vital for our culture and historical heritage.
Small (under 12 hands) hardy and lightweight, Welsh Mountain (Section A) ponies are thrifty feeders that can thrive on poor quality forage; they eat coarser grasses rather than flowering plants and rarely eat heather, which is a priority habitat in both upland and lowland Wales. Their grazing habits can encourage rare flower species by opening up overgrown areas.
Ponies brought from improved grazing may take time to adjust to the inferior diet of conservation sites, unlike hill bred ponies. It follows that they will require more supervision than their upland cousins at least in the early stages. It is a hardy and adaptable breed, which can thrive in the harshest conditions. Mares may lose condition in late pregnancy. Supplementary feed is only recommended in extreme winter conditions. Registered Welsh ponies will normally adapt to seasonal grazing. Their thicker winter coat allows them to withstand exposure to the harsh weather conditions, and their behavioural patterns will predict storms and blizzards a day before and find suitable shelter. Ponies bred on their domain adapt easily to conditions; marsh bred ponies being a classic example of this, where from birth they learn to live with tidal conditions and develop a tolerance to the higher salt content of the plants. Owing to their surefootedness and intelligence they will safely explore dangerous conditions such as bogs and steep rocky terrain.
Welsh Mountain ponies are effective good grazing tools that can assist in the control of bracken, gorse and scrub, preventing areas becoming choked by these plants.
They graze young growth of purple moor grass, which is nutritious but low in minerals. Ponies need access to areas of clean water.
On extensive sites they will choose grazing areas according to the season. Where grazing is extensive, they will ignore rare plants.
They prefer young rush but will eat mature rush when sward is cov-ered by snow. When browsing – they will take some willow or gorse to vary the diet. Willow provides quinine.
On wetlands their relatively light weight is an advantage on wet and boggy sites.
Semi-Feral Welsh Mountain ponies are rarely handled but are suitable for public access sites, provided there is sufficient scope for them to move away from people and dogs.
The Public perception of the Welsh Mountain pony is of a graceful and beautiful breed. Visitors from across the world view and photo-graph the ponies in their natural environment.
As Chair of the WPCS Council and Secretary for the Hill Pony Im-provement Societies in Wales, I fail to see that the BBC and the RSPB have undertaken proper research on the conservation values of the UK’s Native equine breeds. I have set-out some research that I have been involved in with leading ecologists. So, I strongly believe that the Welsh Mountain ponies carry all, if not more suitable characteristics than the Konik ponies.
I am extremely disappointed with the BBC’s statements and the RSPB for using non-UK native ponies and would request a redressing of the misleading item to feature the Native breeds of the UK and in particular the Welsh Mountain pony.
I await your response.
Colin Thomas
Chair of Council the Welsh Pony and Cob Society.
Photograph by kind permission of Buddug Harries on the Preseli Hills taken on Sunday 24th of January 2021