26/10/2025
Well said!
Registration in a club vs. quality of a rodentry.
I often see comments on polish groups that throw around a very misleading sentence: “This rodentry is illegal!”
That kind of statement makes me ick a bit, because when it comes to rodents, there is no legal requirement to register a breeding program - which means that in Poland, every one of them is legal. The good ones and the bad ones alike. Whether they breed for snake food or for pets.
What people usually mean, though, is that a rodentry is not registered. Here the topic becomes a bit more complicated, because while registration isn’t mandatory, for outsiders it’s often seen as the foundation of a good, ethical breeding operation.
And I disagree with that.
Practically since I started breeding, I’ve repeated like a mantra: there are very good unregistered breeders, and very poor registered ones.
Let’s start with what actually makes a good breeder. First and most important, in my opinion, it’s the desire to learn.
When that desire exists and pushes us toward constant improvement, that’s already half the success. Theoretical knowledge prevents serious mistakes, helps us progress faster in selection, set clear breeding goals, and understand what is and isn’t possible.
Another crucial aspect is the ability to provide proper conditions for the species: appropriately sized housing, enrichment, and a correct diet. Because breeding mice in bare plastic bins isn’t hard.
A good breeder will care about what kind of home their rodents go to - whether they’re the right age, healthy, and in good condition. They’ll answer every question and clear up any doubts a new owner may have. The responsibility for an animal doesn’t end with its sale.
Then comes the rather tough part: a good breeder must have a thick skin. Unfortunately (especially with mice), things can hit hard emotionally. Females die during pregnancy, eat their offspring, litters sometimes die from illness, tumors appear in lines, and serious outbreaks can hit the whole rodentry, forcing the breeder to shut everything down. One has to be ready for that.
Finally, there’s the matter of selection skills and clear breeding plans. This isn’t the most important aspect, because those skills usually grow with experience. A young breeder won’t make the same wise decisions as an experienced one - and that’s perfectly normal.
So one question remains: if a breeder meets all those conditions, why not just register for the sake of it and peace of mind?
There can be many reasons: conflicts (a natural thing among people), past traumas, social anxiety, distrust, different values than those of the association, and many more.
I personally believe that unregistered breeders lose a lot - international and community connections can help a breeder grow immensely.
But that doesn’t change one simple fact:
In my opinion, the ability to cooperate is NOT what defines a good breeder.