10/23/2025
Somewhere along the line, we were convinced that setting boundaries is mean.
If we limit access to things our dogs want, add structure to their days, or say “no” sometimes, we’re told we’re being controlling. Harsh. Unkind.
Our dogs deserve better... right? Shouldn't we be giving them choice and agency? Yes, of course - but not all the time.
Boundaries and structure aren’t cruel. They’re kindness. They’re what keep dogs safe, and what help them feel secure.
The trick is in how we set them.
❌ It’s NOT “no — or else.”
❌ It's NOT having a dog live in a crate in a nothing in life is free program - plenty in life should be free.
The “balanced” trainers tell us that boundaries must come with consequences — usually punishment, pain, or fear. The idea that the dog needs to “respect” us or “learn a lesson.”
And on the other end, the purely “force-free” trainers can make people afraid to set any limits at all — as if boundaries and compassion can’t exist in the same space.
❤️But the truth lives in the middle.
Boundaries matter. Many dogs need them.
Actions do have consequences — but those consequences don’t have to involve fear or pain. We can teach through guidance, consistency, and connection instead of intimidation.
We can say “no” without being harsh or punitive.
We can set boundaries and give structure and still be kind.
Many people struggle because they didn’t intend to bring home a dog who needed more. Their last dog didn’t. The dogs they had as a kid didn't. Their neighbor’s dog doesn’t. But this one does.
Maybe it’s a herding breed, a working dog, or just an individual with bigger needs — more drive, more intensity, more sensitivity. These dogs often thrive with structure, clarity, and boundaries. Without them, they struggle.
Boundaries and structure aren’t punishment — they’re a kindness that says I see you and I’ll help you navigate this world.
