10/29/2026
Breed education
How do people decide what breed they want and how do they know that they want it?
It is not uncommon to see owner-bashing posts on social media in response to people struggling with their chosen breed. They all boil down to one claim: “they should have done their research.”
But what if they believe they did and that this “research” is either not that easily accessible or the credibility of those sources that are available is very questionable?
I have been mulling over that problem for a while. 90% of the people who come to us for training either got a dog that it is too much for them to handle, or they rescued a dog that turned out to be different from what the rescue had promised.
The biggest problem, as I see it, is that the honest, credible, unbiased information is just not “out there” and that the people rely on impulse rather than knowledge when getting a dog.
If a person tries to do their research, they will encounter more lies than can be ever named. From published sources, like a book about “100 dog breeds,” which gives a bogus overview of breed traits, to YouTube videos “So you think you want an Australian Shepherd,” which purposefully mislead people by presenting real problems as something that is funny, to online sources that call mutts “Designer breeds,” to rescues that tell soapy stories and make people believe that a shivering shadow of a dog will become a loyal protector with the right owner, to money-hungry breeders who will sell two littermates at a price of one just to make some money.
Lies, lies, and lies that are all made up to perpetuate false information and make people want to buy an animal they are not prepared to own.
On the other hand, impulsive desire to get a dog, and get it “right now” can overpower all logic and good advice. “I looked at him and knew he was mine,” “That breed is so beautiful I had to have one,” or even “The breeder kept the puppies in terrible conditions so I could not just leave her there.”
Sounds familiar?
Impulse and good research cannot exist in the same realm of understanding the world. Moreover, impulse will cancel out any rational thinking, and then you end up with a gamble of a dog.
Where to find reliable sources?
You have to spend time reading the bad ones first, critically thinking and assessing them. This random YouTube content creator with a million of subscribers that jokes about Dobermans - does he know what he is talking about or are you just contributing to his income by watching a video? A Google search that responds to your request about listing top three hypoallergenic breeds - where does it take the information from and does it tell you that no dog is hypoallergenic? The rescue that tries to “sell” a poorly behaved dog under a disguise of systematic abuse - does it want to get rid of a dog that was sitting there too long? That online “match a breed” test you took that told you that the perfect dog for you would be a Labrador - what is the sample size of the breeds it considers?
Once you second-guessed some of your most accessible sources, start digging deeper and ask yourself an honest question: why do I need a dog and what am I going to do with it? Then search for this dog’s breed club and read everything they have on the breed.
Then think about the purpose of this breed. Is it a hunting breed? Then be prepared to deal with nervousness, high prey drive, and recall troubles. Is this a herding breed? Then you will deal with a stalker who won’t leave you alone ever. Guarding breed? Then don’t complain about stubbornness, independence, and aggression. Terrier? God bless your heart. Mixed breed? Then be prepared to deal with the combination of anything and adjust your expectations accordingly.
A good, mentally stable dog that fits your lifestyle can shift your whole world. A nervy, anxious, fearful dog can, too. Which shift is it going to be? Your choice.