05/10/2026
**Maybe she didn’t lose her nerve. Maybe she just gained a life**
This is a slightly different post for a therapy page.
But sometimes the things we talk about in the therapy room show up in the most unexpected places.
For me, one of those places is the horse world.
I’m a mental health clinician, but long before that I was a horse girl.
I spent the first ten years of my life on a 36,000-acre station in the south-west of WA, riding whatever horse happened to be available.
There wasn’t much discussion about confidence. You got on and rode.
As a teenager my parents had a Quarter Horse stud, although I certainly wasn’t riding the expensive horses. I had the cheap ones, the Standardbreds, the ones with a few quirks and the occasional questionable life choice.
There was Pony Club, Prince Philip Games, Adult Riders, Western, English and plenty of kilometres in between.
Then life happens.
You become a parent. Careers grow. Relationships change. Responsibilities increase. Money gets spent elsewhere. Sometimes the things that once formed such a huge part of our identity quietly move into the background.
Maybe you come back to them for a while.
Maybe life takes you away again.
And sometimes you return in your 40s or 50s and discover something strange.
You know more than you ever did, but somehow you feel less brave.
I don’t think we talk about that enough.
And it’s certainly not unique to horses.
People experience it returning to sport, travelling, driving, studying, changing careers, dating, exercising, all sorts of things they once did without giving them much thought.
We often describe it as “losing confidence.”
But I’m not sure that’s always what has happened.
Because confidence isn’t simply a measure of competence.
Sometimes the 45-year-old woman sitting quietly on her horse has vastly more knowledge than the fearless 18-year-old version of herself ever had.
The difference is that the 45-year-old has lived.
She’s seen accidents.
She’s experienced loss.
She understands consequences differently.
She knows what six months unable to work could mean.
She knows what a serious injury could cost her family, her business, her independence and all the other parts of the life she has built.
She has people who depend on her.
The fearless teenager may have been thinking:
“Can I do it?”
The woman she becomes may be asking:
“Is doing it worth the risk?”
Those are very different questions.
That’s not necessarily fear.
Sometimes that’s wisdom.
Sometimes it’s risk assessment.
Sometimes it’s simply having more to lose.
And for many women there may be another layer happening at exactly the same time.
Perimenopause and menopause can affect sleep, mood, anxiety, concentration, fatigue and cognition. Some women describe changes in memory, word retrieval and the ability to juggle multiple pieces of information at once.
So the woman who once heard:
“Outside leg, inside rein, change the bend, pick up the left lead…”
and simply did it may suddenly find herself thinking:
Wait. Which leg? Which rein? What am I doing with my hands? Where am I going?
That doesn’t mean she’s forgotten how to ride.
Her brain may simply be processing the information differently.
Then add something like a late ADHD diagnosis or another form of neurodivergence.
For one rider, “pick up the left lead” might be perfectly adequate instruction.
For another brain, it creates seventeen additional questions.
Left lead according to which direction?
Which one is my inside leg again?
What should that leg be doing?
Where does my outside leg go?
What am I doing with my hands?
When exactly do I ask?
How do I know I’ve got the correct lead?
Am I supposed to be looking somewhere?
And now that I’m thinking about all of that… where am I actually riding?
Meanwhile the instructor is probably wondering why the woman who said she’s been riding for forty years suddenly appears to have forgotten which way is left.
She hasn’t.
Sometimes the instruction simply doesn’t match the brain receiving it.
And I think there’s something much bigger in that.
Instead of asking:
“Why doesn’t she understand what I’m telling her?”
perhaps we could ask:
“How does she learn?”
Instead of:
“Why isn’t she as confident as she used to be?”
perhaps:
“What has changed in her life?”
And instead of assuming hesitation means inability:
“What does she need to feel safe enough to try?”
Those are questions that belong just as comfortably in a therapy room as they do in a riding arena.
Which brings me to something else the horse world has made me think about.
**Unsolicited advice**
I’m also a car person.
And I’ve always found the difference between the two cultures fascinating.
Turn up in an old car with patina, rust and a questionable exhaust and someone will usually wander over and say:
“Bloody cool car.”
Turn up in a beautifully restored classic?
“She’s gorgeous.”
Turn up in a restomod with modern running gear?
“That’s interesting, what have you put in it?”
Of course there are exceptions, but generally there seems to be room for appreciating someone else’s car without needing them to build it exactly as we would.
The horse world can be a little different.
Sometimes somebody can watch a horse and rider for approximately four minutes and suddenly know that the horse is tense, anxious, dropping a shoulder, testing the rider, shutting down, about to explode, and possibly requires a different bit, saddle, trainer, feed, farrier, dentist, bodyworker, riding instructor and probably a priest.
And here’s the thing.
Sometimes they might be right.
There are times when experienced eyes see something we’ve missed. Good trainers, instructors, vets and other horse people have taught me plenty over the years.
Advice can be incredibly valuable.
When it’s wanted.
But there is also enormous value in remembering that the person standing beside that horse may know something we don’t.
They know that horse’s normal.
They know its history.
They know what happened yesterday.
They know what that tiny movement usually means.
They know whether today is unusual.
I’ve got somewhere around 14 horses. I’ve stopped counting accurately because denial is cheaper.
Stallions, colts, geldings, mares and fillies.
Some have frightened me.
Some have restored my confidence.
Some I would put almost anyone on.
Others I wouldn’t.
And I know their normal.
So if my horse lowers its head, perhaps it’s not “shutting down”.
Maybe he’s stretching.
If he looks at something, perhaps he’s not “escalating”.
Maybe he noticed something.
If he drops a shoulder, perhaps I already know he does that.
It doesn’t mean we should never offer another person an observation.
It means we can lead with curiosity rather than certainty.
“Does he normally do that?”
“What do you notice when he does that?”
Or perhaps the simplest one:
“Would you like my thoughts?”
There’s another interesting layer to this.
Horses and humans influence one another.
Research into horse-human interaction has looked at behaviour alongside physiological measures including heart rate, heart-rate variability and cortisol. There is evidence suggesting physiological synchronisation can occur between horses and humans, although the science is still developing and synchronisation itself doesn’t tell us exactly what either horse or person is feeling.
And I think that’s important.
Because it’s very easy to observe:
“That horse is anxious.”
Perhaps he is.
But what is happening in the whole horse-and-human system?
Perhaps the horse is tense.
Perhaps the rider is tense.
Perhaps they’re influencing one another.
Perhaps neither is particularly anxious and we’re interpreting ordinary behaviour through our own expectations.
The same thing happens between humans.
We observe behaviour and then create a story to explain it.
She’s quiet, therefore she’s angry.
He’s withdrawn, therefore he doesn’t care.
She’s hesitant, therefore she’s incapable.
She’s nervous on that horse, therefore she can’t ride.
The observation may be accurate.
The story we attach to it may not be.
That’s one of the reasons curiosity is usually more useful than certainty.
And perhaps that’s the point of this very long horse-and-psychology thought.
I sit with people in the therapy room who tell me about losing confidence in things they once loved.
About feeling embarrassed because something that used to be easy suddenly isn’t.
About worrying that other people are watching.
About feeling stupid because they don’t immediately understand an instruction.
About avoiding something they desperately want to do because they’re frightened they’ll be judged.
Sometimes they eventually stop doing it altogether.
And when we explore it, sometimes we discover they didn’t actually lose their ability.
Life changed around it.
Their body changed.
Their brain changed.
Their responsibilities changed.
Their perception of risk changed.
Their experiences changed.
Or the environment around them stopped feeling safe enough to be imperfect in.
And perhaps that’s something all of us can think about, horse people or otherwise.
Before offering advice, ask if it’s wanted.
Before assuming someone lacks knowledge, get to know them.
Before interpreting someone else’s experience, get curious about what you don’t know.
Before calling someone nervous, consider what they’ve lived through.
Before deciding someone “can’t” consider whether they simply learn differently.
And before talking about the person who isn’t there…
perhaps remember how easily our observations can turn into somebody else’s story.
There is room in the horse world for the fearless 18-year-old.
There is room for the 50-year-old getting back on after twenty years.
There is room for the woman who wants to gallop.
There is room for the woman who is perfectly happy walking.
There is room for competition riders, trail riders, nervous riders, neurodivergent riders, beginners and people with forty years of experience who are suddenly discovering that confidence looks different now.
And outside the horse world, the same principle applies.
You don’t have to be the person you were at 20 to prove that person is still somewhere inside you.
You don’t have to do something simply because you once could.
And you don’t have to take somebody else’s risk to prove your own courage.
Perhaps one of the privileges of getting older is knowing yourself well enough to say:
“No thanks. That’s not a risk I need to take anymore.”
Or:
“Yes, I want to do this, but I’m going to do it differently this time.”
Maybe she didn’t lose her nerve.
Maybe she just gained a life worth protecting.