31/08/2025
Itâs disappointing, though not surprising, that instead of engaging with the substance of my recent Paulick Report op-ed, Colbyâs Crew Rescue chose to respond with name-calling and personal attacks. Ad hominem is the lowest form of communication. Itâs a distraction from facts and data, and earnest readers should see it for what it is.
The irony is that their ârebuttalâ claims they donât disparage other rescues, yet it is written as an attempt to discredit and embarrass me personally rather than share meaningful data-based information that supports their position. The op-ed was not about CCR, but if the shoe fits, theyâre welcome to wear it.
To be clear: I have never told anyone not to support them, and I donât âhateâ CCR. What I do object to, loudly and unapologetically, is the exploitative model of kill pen bailout schemes, which even kill buyer David OâDwyer admitted was essentially a marketing tactic when he announced that a recent lot of 11 Thoroughbred yearlings with a posted "ship date" were never at risk of being killed.
The facts are not in dispute:
-Shipping manifests show the horses who go to slaughter are young, healthy, and overwhelmingly Standardbreds and Quarter Horsesânot minis, donkeys, or drafts.
-Records from Canada confirm this.
-Slaughter exports from the U.S. to Canada are actually increasing.
These are documented facts, not opinions. If someone tells you not to question them, but only to âtake our word for it,â ask yourself why.
Our position is simple: prevention should be prioritized over response. That means focusing on owner surrenders, breeding restrictions, aftercare programs, and long-term solutions that reduce the number of horses entering the pipeline in the first place. If you donât agree with that, then youâre essentially saying youâd rather wait until a horse is in the hands of a kill buyer.
I know many individuals and organizations quietly support this stance but stay silent out of fear of retaliation. An organization bullying others into silence is unacceptable. Respectful debate should always be welcome in this space.
So letâs bring it back, once again, to facts and data - not rhetoric, or insults. Because the horses deserve better.