10/15/2026
Why Good People (and good dogs) sometimes look like bad owners (and bad dogs).
"Why can't you control your dog"?
"You should train your dog"!
"You shouldn't have a dog you can't handle".
"That's not the right dog for you".
These are just some of the criticisms that the owners of reactive, excited, struggling, traumatized, aggressive, young or new dogs face.
We've all seen a struggling dog owner being yanked around by a lunging, barking, out of control dog, and for many people, it's all too easy to diagnose the situation- "an inept or lazy owner with a dog they can't handle". And sometimes they're right. The truth is, sometimes people are foolish and arrogantly select breeds they can't handle. Sometimes people are lazy and don't take the time to train their dog. It's true. But what's also true, is that in many cases, someone can wind up with an out of control dog due to no fault of their own. The other half of the truth is that people and dogs have bad moments (that they work through), people and dogs face struggles (that they overcome), people and dogs wind up in unpredictable situations, and they even face unexpected adversities (that they then must recover from).
As a trainer, I've had the great honor of helping many people during their toughest moments as dog owners, and I'd like to share with you some of the reasons why good people (and good dogs) sometimes look like bad owners (and bad dogs).
1) Lack of Education and Misinformation.
While there is a ton of information out there, there's still no universal, all inclusive manual on all things canine. There's no single trainer who has seen it all and knows everything, there’s no required course or license to own a dog. But there are tons of examples of trainers admitting "I was wrong". There are authors who have taken back advice they've given in their books or training manuals, "experts" who claimed to know it all but who actually knew nothing, and well meaning friends who speak from experience they didn't know was limited. Sometimes, good dog owners just plain taught the wrong thing, and then find out abruptly and unceremoniously that they were sorely misinformed. By that point though, sometimes a great deal of damage has already been done that must then be overcome. I have worked with clients who were advised to use training techniques that worsened their problems, I've worked with clients whose dogs have come home from board and train facilities with new issues, and I've worked with people who were poorly advised by a close family member who "used to be a breeder". I've even known people who experienced "training scams" and spent hundreds of dollars for a fake certificate.
2) Dogs don’t conform to breed standards as closely as some people think.
Just like people, dogs come in a wide range of personalities and individualities, and if I’ve learned anything working with so many people, it’s that you can’t predict a dog's behavior just based on the breed. Sometimes, you meet a dog that's one in a million. A quiet Husky that doesn't pull, a terrier that doesn't chase, or a champion working dog that never needed a single training session in their lives. For people who have significant personal experience with an extreme example of a breed, it can be hard to imagine another of “the same dog” acting so differently. Even people with repeated experience with dogs of the same breed can find themselves surprised by an abnormally energetic, unusually driven, or peculiarly aggressive dog.
3) Rescue and Rehoming Situations.
Life is what happens while you’re making other plans. No matter how hard we try, we can’t account for everything, sometimes things just don’t work out, emergencies happen, and sometimes people have no choice but to immediately rehome their dog. In some cases, people with big hearts take on a challenge with an emergency rescue situation, and take canines in need into their homes. People who adopt and rescue, especially in emergency situations, don’t always have the luxury of carefully selecting the perfect dog. Dogs in immediate need can come with special needs, unique problems and old bad habits, and it can take new rescuers a little time to figure out their new companion- or vice versa. Sometimes experienced working breeds wind up in shelters and must adapt to a new life as an indoor pet with significantly less exercise or stimulation.
4) A New Challenge.
As some dog owners grow in skill, they might find themselves feeling ready to take on a new challenge and become the owners of a particularly elusive, unique, specialized or lifelong dream breed. Even with a great deal of education and experience, a challenging breed can still be a challenge. It takes some time for new owners to adapt to managing an extremely energetic, strong and driven dog.
5) Inheritance, Gifts and Divorce.
People don’t always choose their dog. Sometimes they receive well intended gifts, sometimes parents purchase a “dog for the kids” that’s actually just a breed they’ve always wanted, sometimes people receive an unexpected dog in a will or a divorce. Sometimes newly single pet parents find that managing their dog single-handedly becomes especially challenging with half the time, energy and hands.
6) Misidentification.
The A.K.C. recognizes 205 dog breeds, and many of them don't even account for a percent of the dogs owned. Every now and then, shelters advertise a new adoptable "German Shepherd", who is actually a Belgian Malinois, or a "labrador mix" that looks strangely similar to a Great Pyrenees. Sometimes unexpected litters come from unknown places, but "we are pretty sure it's the guy next door with the Golden Retriever". Sometimes people straight up lie about the breed they have in order to bypass legal restrictions, apartment or neighborhood regulations, or public discrimination. I've worked with clients who thought they were getting one thing, did the research, and wound up with another breed entirely. Misidentification can be an honest mistake, an attempt at discretion, or an unethical scam, but regardless of the reason, sometimes people wind up with a surprise they weren’t prepared for.
7) Incidents.
When a dog owner faces unexpected health challenges or even major injuries, they might rely on friends or family members to assist with caring for their dog. Without the same relationship and familiarity, these helpful humans can face major challenges managing a dog that is not only powerful, but stressed.
When a well trained dog suffers a traumatic event, it can cause drastic and sudden changes in temperament, behavior and obedience. In some cases, such as injury, accidents or assaults, dogs can develop the canine equivalent of PTSD, and will become uncharacteristically fearful or aggressive, reactive and unmanageable. In one particular case, I worked with a dog owner who had an aggressive dog climb the fence and attack her Lab-Dane mix in his own backyard. Her previously friendly dog was suddenly uncontrollable with other dogs in sight. It took well over a year of training before he was able to control his anxiety and aggression around other dogs.
8) We all have bad days, and occasionally make bad decisions in spite of our better judgments and previous educational experiences. A bad moment, or a bad decision, on a bad day, can lead to a bad situation. Even experienced trainers make mistakes that leave them wondering “Why on Earth did I do that”? In these moments, we need to learn from our mistakes, but we also need a little grace and a little patience.
If someone wants a new dog, they can't necessarily be expected to have prior experience with that breed. You can't just walk up to a stranger and say "Hey, we don't know each other, but can I borrow your dog to see if I want one of these for myself"? Sometimes the person holding the leash is learning how to handle their new dog through hands-on practice, sometimes they're a helping hand in a time of need, and sometimes they're a person just working through a tough moment, having a bad day, suffering a major loss, or overcoming a traumatic event. The point is, there are so many scenarios that might look bad from the outside that I couldn't hope to mention them all.
Sometimes, a bad moment is just a bad moment, and while it’s true that some people are in fact bad, irresponsible dog owners, it’s just as true that great dog owners, and great dogs struggle sometimes.