10/28/2026
From the brilliant mind of Shay Kelly.
THE 10 CONTRADICTIONS
1 The dog needs consequences.
True – All operant behaviour relies on consequences, but it doesn’t rely on coercion, physical assault, shocking, pronging or asphyxiation.
2 It’s just communication.
False - Pain, fear, or startle responses aren’t communication, they’re coercion. Communication involves understanding, not avoidance.
3 Punishment tools don’t hurt.
FALSE - If it didn’t cause discomfort, it wouldn’t suppress the behaviour. The dog is trying to avoid the discomfort – that’s the change you see.
4 It’s just a correction.
False - A ‘correction’ that reduces the behaviour is by definition, punishment. Would they call it a correction if they got zapped for everything they do that I do not approve of? I think they’d call it abuse.
5 The dog must learn respect.
IRRELEVANT- Respect has nothing to do with fearing of consequences, which is usually what they mean when they vomit this nonsense.
6 Positive reinforcement doesn’t work with all dogs.
FALSE - Learning theory isn’t reliant on the individual trainer’s skill, care, commitment, or ethics. Some people can’t point to Canada on a map – it doesn’t mean it’s not there.
7 Balanced is superior because it uses all four quadrants.
FALSE - The mere fact that positive punishment exists as a way of understanding behaviour is not a recommendation for its use in teaching animals. What B.F. Skinner actually said about it was “In the long run, punishment, unlike reinforcement, works to the disadvantage of both the punished and the punisher.” It’s a bit like putting potatoes in your victory sponge mix and claiming it makes a superior cake because you used more ingredients 🤷♂️
8 I love dogs, I’d never hurt them.
REALLY? - If you use pain-based tools (prong, shock, choke), you are inflicting pain. Claiming otherwise is emotional rationalisation to ease cognitive dissonance. You are bullying the dog into submission - not training them.
9 Dogs need structure and leadership.
TRUE - They’re domesticated and rely on us, but structure doesn’t require fear. Predictability, reinforcement, consistency and clarity provide structure without intimidation.
10 Positive punishment works.
TRUE - It does indeed, but it often ignores ethics, the dog’s experience, and the possible unintended side effects of stress, fear, and aggression. It’s often the method of choice for those who do not care about the dog’s experience or those without in-depth behaviour knowledge. Unfortunately, this only serves to worsen the dog’s experience. Novichok ‘works’ but that doesn’t mean we should put it on our cornflakes.