29/05/2026
Roaming with Hounds Diary
Dog Body "Language" & Relational Observation
Big words, a?!
Well, i watched a video on my Facebook thread last night of a bull breed dog getting pats from a human kneeling next to the dog. The dog had bulging eyes, sat on its side, right stifle folded under, the dog pushes his head forward a bit lifting his lip very slighly when the human pointed at his left eye, he lip licked once, the human got up turned, the dog got up, turned, sliped while moving forwards, then looked back as the human stopped, dog turned again, shook its body and off it went.
The question was, if people thought the dog was enjoying this interaction.
And if observational "science" were up to democratic voting, the "No's" and the "OMG" had it [1.]
I kept on scrolling just to see if anyone pointed out the most worrying factor in the video.
"How the dog sat!"
I must admit I didnt scroll through all 120plus No's, OMG's and long-winded opinion pieces of body language. I stopped at a very interesting comment from a replier, that what as uncomfortable but much more diplomatic then I could be.
The post started something like this: "I am gonna be outvoted on this, but...."
The "but", intrigued me instantly, because it infered a thought process deeper then the general classifiers of the "No's" and "OMG's".
It infered a relational thought process.
This person pointed out that it was a 20 seconds video, of a breed that some have bulging eyes, of a relational incident between a handler and dog, of whom's relationship we do not have information about.
This well pointed out comment was quickly answered by, this is the foster carer and the dog came from a kill shelter.
Again, the person pointed out that that information added to the video, but she was still not overly confident of "judging" whether the dog enjoyed it or not.
To me, she was the most interesting commenter. Because she understood that every detail matters. She understood, that physical signals have no universal essence- one meaning- like many words have. Body language is nothing like spoken words.
Body language is a way to communicate through movement, and movement is inherently relational!!
It depends how things move in relation to eachother and other things.
And the way we observe them, rest in our past experience- of phylogenetic and learned origins.
We cannot escape that bias, but we can do better then group thinking- and that lady showed it. She had the currage to point something very important out. And for that I salute her.
Why have I posted this, with a picture of black blobs?
Well, here is your visual exercise to "reinforce" the above point.
Look at the picture of all the black blobs on the white back ground. What do YOU observe?
Write it down.
The answer is in the comments.
If you have seen this Pic before, sorry it will likely not work for you anymore, because you have succumb to the bias of the original picture.
1.[For discussion please first read Thomas Naigles "What its like to be a bat"]
2. Picture by R C James, Life Magazine, 19th Feb 1965, 58; 7, p120