08/06/2026
On the debate of harness vs collar, where do we stand?
The short answer? We work and train with both! The long answer? It is completely dependent on the situation, location and stage in training.
*Disclaimer: there are lots of different trainers out there who train in their own specific ways and each may be equally valid, this is simply what I do and methods I have developed over time and working with lots of different dogs*
This is Ash at 4.5 months old, taking on her first country road walk to visit the sheep near the village🐑 At this stage in her training, my goal is purely socialisation and building confidence- not behavior or obedience. I want to find the easiest way to get her down the road safely and comfortably, without making loose lead walking harder to teach when we start to tackle it later on. So I picked a harness and a light 3m lead to give her plenty of room to sniff, explore and check out the sights and sounds without hitting the end of a lead! She is too young for now for me to expect her to heel for an extended period of time (currently boasting the attention span on a gnat and is easily distracted by shiny objects) so putting her lead on her collar would only end up with a lot of tension on her neck or a very stop start walk-frustrating for both me and her! So for now we explore on a harness (still reinforcing loose-lead walking but making it much easier for Ash to get right) and collar training will come later, with heel work will be built up gradually until we are ready to use it for longer training walks🤞
For Aspen and Ash in the future, wearing their walking harness will tell them they are 'off-duty' and they can relax and do their thing, whereas walking on a collar will mean they are 'working' and need to stay engaged with their handler. In this way they can be both pets and life savers for someone very special.
📨If you'd like to register your interest in partnering with one of these pups once they are fully trained or to find out more, email [email protected]