28/06/2025
Why Your Dog’s Behaviour Still Doesn’t Make Sense
It might be a mystery, not a puzzle
You’ve made changes. You’ve tried the better harness and lead, the quieter walk, the food they normally love. You’ve watched closely. You’ve adjusted. You’ve given it your best guess.
And still, your dog reacts or does something you didn’t expect.
You think, “I thought we were past this.”
Or, “I just don’t understand it anymore.”
I often describe behaviour as a puzzle, because sometimes it is.
There are pieces to observe, patterns to follow, and details that gradually start to make sense.
But not all behaviour works like that.
Some behaviour feels less like a puzzle and more like a mystery.
A puzzle gives you all the pieces. You just have to fit them together.
A mystery doesn’t. You notice things slowly. Patterns don’t always appear right away.
It’s about understanding what might be contributing to behaviour in this moment, even if the full picture isn’t clear yet.
Many guardians I meet have already spent a long time trying to figure things out.
They’ve changed walks, routines, equipment, even rewards.
They’ve made thoughtful adjustments. They’ve been showing up for their dog, every day.
And yet the behaviour still shows up or disappears and then returns without warning.
It’s easy to feel like something’s been missed.
That if you could just find the missing piece, it would all make sense again.
I see this often with guardians supporting dogs who react in ways that seem inconsistent or difficult to read.
The behaviour can look unpredictable, but there’s usually something contributing to it that we couldn’t see straight away.
Like the dog who suddenly barks and lunges at another dog across the road, even though they were walking calmly a moment ago, even though they’ve walked that same route all week, even though you’ve practised every strategy you know.
But not everything is meant to be worked out straight away.
Sometimes there’s more going on beneath the surface.
Sometimes there’s a pattern you can’t see yet.
Sometimes it’s just more complicated than it looks.
Some behaviours are genuinely complex.
Like many real-life mysteries, they’re shaped by multiple influences: emotion, previous learning history, genetics, reproductive status, health.
And the reasons aren’t always immediately clear.
Mystery doesn’t mean confusion. It means something deeper is going on, something we might not see clearly at first, but that still matters.
It asks us to observe rather than explain.
To notice what’s there without rushing to label it.
To stay present with the behaviour in front of us, even when it doesn’t make sense yet.
That doesn’t mean doing nothing. But it does mean stepping back from urgency.
Because when we stop looking for a quick solution, we often start to see more of what’s really going on.
Some behaviours don’t give you the full picture straight away.
You might not know what’s behind them yet.
You might never know entirely and that’s OK.
Some answers come slowly, and some don’t come at all.
But your support still matters.
You can prioritise safety.
You can reduce pressure.
You can support your dog in ways that make daily life feel more manageable for both of you.
And you can explore whether your dog’s behaviour might also be caused by pain, discomfort, or underlying health conditions, even ones that don’t show up clearly in everyday life.
If your dog’s behaviour still doesn’t make sense, this is the kind of thing I help with.
Not all behaviour can be solved straight away.
Some of it needs time, compassion, and someone who can sit with the mystery too.