13/07/2025
THIS!!
Best in Show â Best for the Breed
Why Top Show Dogs Arenât Always Top Breeding Dogs
Itâs a question that often divides breeders, judges, and fanciers alike:
Are the best show dogs really the best breeding dogs?
The answerâwhen stripped of glamour and ribbonsâis often no. And not because show dogs lack quality, but because the system rewards what catches the eye, not always what sustains the breed.
Letâs unpack that.
The Problem with âThe Lookâ
The show ring often favors flash. A dog with exaggerated featuresâwhether itâs coat, reach and drive, head size, or extreme angulationâstands out under the lights. Judges, like all humans, are susceptible to what looks impressive in motion or in profile. This doesnât mean theyâre failingâit means the system favors visibility over subtlety.
But exaggeration often comes at a cost:
⢠That ultra-long neck? May compromise breathing or balance.
⢠That extreme rear? May lead to joint strain or instability.
⢠That massive head? May affect whelping ease or overall mobility.
These dogs may excel in competition, but that doesnât mean their genes will move the breed forward.
Breeding is Bigger Than a Rosette
Breeding should prioritize:
⢠Correct structure, not just dramatic movement.
⢠Stable, predictable temperaments suitable for the breedâs function.
⢠Health, fertility, and longevity, not just short-term wins.
⢠Function over flashâespecially in working or performance breeds.
When a breeder uses a top-winning dog as a stud just because itâs a Champion or BIS winner, they may be breeding toward a show imageânot toward the breedâs future.
When a Title Doesnât Mean Competition
Hereâs a hard truth in dog sports:
You can finish almost any dog if youâre willing to travel, spend money, and play the system.
Thatâs why we can only talk about meaningful wins when:
⢠The breed entries are large enough to create real competition.
⢠The dogs defeated are of known, high quality.
⢠The judges have a reputation for prioritizing breed type over showmanship.
A Champion title earned in a sparsely entered ring or against mediocre dogs doesnât prove breed worthinessâit proves effort, money, and strategy.l
So, What Makes a Dog âBreed Worthyâ?
Not just a title. Not just a win photo.
But a total evaluation:
⢠Structure, health, and temperament.
⢠Pedigree depth and predictability.
⢠Ability to contribute something meaningful to the next generation.
Sometimes that dog is a Champion. Sometimes itâs a moderate, sound, unremarkable mover who will never catch a judgeâs eyeâbut will consistently produce puppies that are better than herself.
Thatâs breeding.
Dog shows can be a valuable tool. But they are just one piece of the puzzle. A great show dog may sometimes be a great producerâbut only when paired with purpose-driven, honest breeding decisions.
If the ribbons are blinding you to faults, if the glamour outweighs the geneticsâitâs time to step out of the spotlight and back into reality.
Because a breed isnât built on what wins today.
Itâs built on what thrives tomorrow.
Copied and shared from Sakari Joenväärä's post. :)