15/07/2025
đŤ Deemed Unfit for Use â A Hard but Necessary Conversation đŤ
This is a topic that rarely gets discussed openly.
While Iâm proud of my success rate, the reality is that not every horse who comes through my gate is suitable for the job they were intended for. There are times when a horse is deemed unsafe or unfit for use under saddle, and while itâs never an easy decisionâespecially when working closely with an ownerâit is one that must be made with care, responsibility, and honesty.
Some horses present with serious behavioural issues or dangerous vices. Whether those issues can be worked through often comes down to one critical factor: work ethic. A horse's willingness and attitude can mean the difference between a successful riding career, being rehomed to a more suitable situation, being retired to a paddockâor in the most unfortunate cases, being humanely euthanised. Iâve met horses I truly believed were a danger to future riders, and while itâs confronting, safety must come first.
Itâs important for ownersâespecially those purchasing unbroken horsesâto understand: you are not starting with a clean slate. Youâre buying a horse you havenât seen ridden, and havenât ridden yourself. A great relationship on the ground does not guarantee the same connection in the saddle. Thatâs why part of my role is assessing not just the horse, but also the riderâs ability, experience, and intentions moving forward.
The most concerning situations often arise when owners overestimateâor aren't forthcoming with their riding experience. Breaking in a horse is not about delivering a ready-made schoolmaster. Youâre receiving a green horse with developing skills and a need for continued consistent training. Sending a young or challenging horse home to a rider who isnât confident or capable puts everyone at risk.
When I make the call that a horse isnât suitable, I donât wait until the end of their stay. I will usually let the owner know by week two, once ridden work has begun. Occasionally, if Iâm unsure, I may take until week three. But I donât believe in continuing to take your money for a horse I donât believe will bring you joy or success. When this happens, I give you options: take the horse home, or allow them to stay longer and continue training with full transparency.
Even if a horse leaves my program early, I do my best to support owners by offering guidance and advice on how to move forward safely and realistically.
This job isnât always sunshine and rainbows. Sometimes, you're the last chance a horse gets. The responsibility of making the right callâfor the horse and for the riderâcarries real weight.
At the end of the day, you donât pay me to tell you what you want to hearâyou pay me to tell you the truth.